Demystifying MOBAs https://videogametourism.at/ de Demystifying MOBAs - a word from the editor https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-word-editor <span>Demystifying MOBAs - a word from the editor</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/demy_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/demy_0.jpg?itok=SGB4_YoC" width="700" height="291" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/rainer-sigl" class="username">Rainer Sigl</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-11-19T21:32:09+01:00" title="Donnerstag, 19 November 2015 - 21:32">Do. 19 Nov 2015 - 21:32</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>When Eron asked me a while back if VGT would be willing to run a series of essays on the aesthetics, the design and infrastructure of MOBAs, I agreed blindly. And in a literal sense, too: Although I have been playing video games for a quarter of a century and nowadays even earn part of my rent writing about them, I was pitifully ignorant of a phenomenon that is not even just the future, but very much the present of video games.</p> <p>As Eron writes in his introduction:</p> <p><em>The broader problem in talking about video games in a nuanced way is massively amplified with MOBAs since [they] are tricky for both lay and academic audiences, especially since it can take literally hundreds of hours to learn to play these games with any amount of skill, let alone to explore their communities.</em></p> <p>This hits home especially for those writing about games professionally: In the already hectic circle of news-previews-release-reviews-oblivion, there is simply no time for most journalists to spend that amount of time on a single game, period. (And to point out a fact most readers of games journalism might be unaware of: Most of the men and women writing about games who are lucky enough to be paid at all, are freelancers. That means they are paid for <em>the text</em>, and <em>not</em> for the time spent playing the game they report on. It's only the absolute minority of games journalists, usually those actually employed by the few remaining specialist outlets, print or online, for whom play time is paid work time. Let that sink in for a minute.) The title of this series is well chosen: It is a de-mystification that's going on here, all right, and a very welcome one at that.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">It's bad form hyping your own content, so I'll just say this much: You should read this.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Eron's articles have been featured on VGT for a while; I was proud to feature his series <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">"Bridging Worlds"</a> for a few years now. And still I was quite unprepared for the scope of his series on MOBAs, a scope I can only now grasp fully, after his series has ended. It's bad form hyping your own content, so I'll just say this much: You should read this, no matter if you're already playing MOBAs or, like me, just stand at a distance, wondering at the chorus of millions cheering for a sport that seems to come straight out of a Philip K. Dick novel.</p> <p>"Demystifying MOBAs", eight essays, 30,000 words total, can be read in the tiniest fracture of time it would take you to understand the basic nuances of character picking in either of the big MOBAs. It's a long read, yes, but it's worth it.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>I think one of the reasons this series is actually unique is that it manages to both introduce its subject and also speak to long-time MOBA fans. For easier reference, here's the links to the individual articles again. Thanks again, Eron!</p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> </ul> </div> Thu, 19 Nov 2015 20:32:09 +0000 Rainer Sigl 639 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - The Heralds of High Drama https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama <span>Demystifying MOBAs - The Heralds of High Drama</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_6.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_6.jpg?itok=77inwXuZ" width="700" height="200" alt title="Famous pro wresting announcer Bobby Heenan and equally snazzy dresser, Dota2 caster Bruno “Bruno” Carlucci."> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-11-18T09:48:11+01:00" title="Mittwoch, 18 November 2015 - 09:48">Mi. 18 Nov 2015 - 09:48</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs. This is the final part.</em></p> <p>Watching ten people sit hidden behind computer monitors on a stage might sound like the very stuff that purgatory is built of, with a barrage of swirling laser lights and dubstep blasting only adding insult to injury. But a massive number of people have come to love watching esports, and by massive I mean top tournaments for <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (aka <em>Dota2</em>, by Valve Corporation) and <em>League of Legends</em> (aka <em>LoL</em>, by Riot Games) can draw tens of millions of viewers, which is on par with top traditional sporting events like the baseball World Series. Blizzard/Activision’s <em>Heroes of the Storm</em> (<em>HotS</em>) doesn’t draw quite as many viewers, but was only launched in the middle of 2015, and is backed by the company that has historically been a pioneer of esports via <em>StarCraft</em>.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Aside from the interest of amateur players in seeing the best plays in their favorite game, part of the attraction is that these events are produced to resemble a reality show version of massive medieval pageants. As David Shoemaker has laid out in an amazing book called <em>The Squared Circle</em>, professional (aka staged) wresting started as a circus sideshow and has wandered the back alleys of culture through generations of children through iconic characters from World Wresting Entertainment (WWE) like the (now disgraced) all-American mustachioed Hulk Hogan and the villainous (possibly undead) Undertaker. Shoemaker’s critical point is that almost unnoticed, professional wrestling’s style of storytelling, with its soap opera mix of reality show theatrics and stark dramatic archetypes, has become the core way that almost all sports broadcasting is handled. Combining reality television’s heightened drama with broad theatrical tropes for telling stories of struggle and triumph turns out to be a formula that can salve the oft-chaffing complexity of sports arcana for novices and the boredom that broadcasters dread during dull parts of the game. In esports, how can you do anything but cheer for the plucky SumaiL (Syed Sumail Hasan) as the casters explicate how he started playing at eight years old in Pakistan and was so poor he had to sell his bike to get money to play <em>Dota2</em>, emigrated around the world to play for the American team Evil Geniuses, and now at age 16 is sitting on stage in the finals with ten million dollars on the line?</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/1_7.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/1_7.jpg?itok=9ITmBEVo" width="700" height="359" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>LoL</em> is the industry leader at promoting MOBAs as esports, and a large part of that reputation rests on their rapid professionalization, almost weaponization, of their esports broadcasts. One of their big influences is actually the much-maligned Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC). Though this seems odd at first glance, this association makes complete sense if you understand that one of the quintessential problems that UFC presents to a viewer is that the sport is literally “Mixed Martial Arts” (MMA) meaning that matches span dozens and dozens of different historical and complex martial arts from all over the world. A given match might take elements from the Israeli army’s self-defense system, ancient Chinese styles, and Western boxing, used in combinations and modulations all within another rule set for scoring implemented by the UFC. Even the most dedicated viewer can’t be expected to understand the specifics of Muay Thai kickboxing as well as Olympic wrestling and how they interact.</p> <p>The same problem exists in MOBAs, with a hoard of complex characters, items, and rule interactions that beguile even the casters. But borrowing the traditions of professional wrestling, the production teams in MMA build narratives around the athletes while simultaneously relativizing the actual sporting elements. The production team might explain the match as, “This one guy has six kids and is fighting to make his sickly Dad proud, while in the other corner you have a bad boy who races motorcycles and talks trash about everyone,” which sets up the emotional and narrative stakes. Then during the match, the MMA broadcasters will tend to take open moments to explain the most stripped down version of the technical aspects, such as, “This fighter is really strong at punching, but not very fast, so the other fighter, who is weaker but more nimble, can only win through cunning and high risk maneuvers.” These framing aspects of emotional stories and broad technical explanations are amplified and reiterated throughout a match and highlighted during the inevitable pregame videos with the athletes where they are shown training, talking, and even hanging out at their houses just like in reality TV.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/2_7.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/2_7.jpg?itok=4oJQeBUP" width="700" height="329" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Unlike baseball which historically had one announcer, modern sports broadcasting, including esports, uses a variety of analysts and casters to create tension and drama. The first of these groups is made up of former professional players and high level statisticians with a personable moderator, and they handle the pre-game and post-game breakdowns. The analysts become something of a sideshow themselves, dramatically arguing about the correctness of their opinions and statistics often with the aid of silly props. During the match there are two or three casters, one of which does play-by-play while the second is a “color” commentator who mixes together repetitive explanations of fundamentals and exciting descriptions in the form of humorously elaborate analogies. If there is a third person on the caster desk it is either a fan favorite personality as a guest, or a former pro that has specific experience that is relevant to the match. <em>LoL</em> followed this system fairly closely when it built its broadcasting style, and <em>Dota2</em> and <em>HotS</em> have followed suit.</p> <p>Riot Games’ decision to adopt modern sports stylings and systems has even affected non-MOBA games like <em>StarCraft</em> which have traditionally been under the sway of the Korean model of broadcasting, which is more akin to the way that football radio announcers compete to whip each other into a constant verbal flurry. <em>Dota2</em> has even provided some interesting additions to the now-typical MOBA style and hired a professional improv comedian Kaci Aitchison, who barely knew anything about the game when she started her tenure but brought a wealth of on-screen experience, to fill the role of host for the last two International tournaments. Her role was to bind together the diverse broadcast elements and act as a strong on-screen character counterbalance to the more inside-baseball and proud-amateur nerdy aspects of the typical MOBA esports production.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/3_8.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/3_8.jpg?itok=01bLo0WG" width="700" height="418" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>So far I’ve left out <em>HotS</em> because there have been so few major tournaments that getting a consistent sense of style has been difficult. Most of the smaller <em>HotS</em> tournaments have been held online, so typically it’s up to the caster or casters to determine the broadcast style themselves and talk through the drama in front of a home green screen setup, occasionally joined by their cat. This relatively amateur aspect of <em>HotS</em> casting has actually been discussed with great nostalgia by fans who have grown used to the ultra-slick <em>LoL</em> broadcasts. Even with my interest in this realm of esports, a large part of my love for it was based on how little it resembled the overly-loud, overly-manic television sporting events. The absolute antithesis of the overly slick and commercialized sports broadcasts is epitomized by the infamous <em>StarCraft</em> tournament HomeStory Cup, which while a major event, was also based on a premise that flew in the face of all traditional models.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">Some fans, myself included, fear that unfettered professionalization will sterilize the fun and goofiness that initially drew so many players to esports.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>The idea for HomeStory Cup was simple: some of the top casters in Europe would invite a couple dozen top players in the world to live with them for a week and play a complete tournament in their living room. People slept on the floor, went to the bar downstairs, cooked communal pots of chili, and played poker, all while the matches were going on. It was complete chaos, but led to untold amusing off-the-cuff storytelling moments combined with incredible access to the best players in the world; also a massive number of hangovers. Some fans, myself included, fear that unfettered professionalization will sterilize the fun and goofiness that initially drew so many players to esports. In fact, the height of stilted esports events was recently achieved by the <em>HotS</em> Heroes of the Dorm series, which felt more like an infomercial than a tournament. The analyst desk was clearly reading from a stilted teleprompter script for a vast majority of the broadcast, and spent most of their time pitching reasons to play the game while canned promo footage ran on the screens behind them.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/4_8.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/4_8.jpg?itok=XGSfm_tS" width="700" height="399" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>New Models</strong></p> <p>While the UFC and WWE models are the most dominant, one aspect that makes esports unique from traditional sports is that the players are actually manipulating characters that exist in a unique narrative world. However hokey and trite, in <em>LoL</em> Jarvan IV and Shyvana are characters who have an elaborate melodramatic relationship to each other and the world around them. If they are both on a team together, casters could talk about J4 and Shy’s old friendship, while if they are opposed there is the story of the falling out of the warrior prince and the fearsome but lonely half-dragon. In some ways, casting esports can resemble the nearly-lost Japanese tradition of the the <em>benshi</em>. The <em>benshi</em> was a person who stood beside the movie screen during the era of silent films and theatrically and improvisationally, told/re-told/remixed the narrative to the audience. <em>StarCraft 2</em> casts (especially those under the helm of personality Day9) often resembles this style of narrative improvisation, where during slow moments casters retell the what happened in the match in story form. Perhaps it is a heroic story of a group of space marines who were valiantly sneaking into the alien base and managed to discover a completely unexpected army of giant bugs; perhaps it is a tragic story a group of perfectly content workers, mining on an asteroid that were ambushed and evaporated by a cloaked alien ship.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/EFjYddcPM0w" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFjYddcPM0w" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFjYddcPM0w</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Laden with these sorts of RPG and mythic elements, future MOBAs and esports could exploit or emphasize this theatrical element in novel ways. In fact <em>Smite</em>, the fourth most popular MOBA, can be very strange to watch as a spectator since all of the characters are gods and goddesses from traditional mythologies. “Zeus cast a lighting bolt but Aphrodite dodged it and Bacchus got angry and tried to beat Zeus with a wine jug,” is a perfectly legitimate narrative both for the ten players sitting at computers around the world playing <em>Smite</em> and for a band of Greek warriors telling stories around a campfire on a beach during a siege some 3000 years ago. But even more interesting are recent advances in the use of augmented reality elements in esports broadcasts. That is, elements that blur the boundaries between two dimensional screen and the real world. The recent <em>Dota2</em> International had a stage that was set up in the middle of the stadium, similar to a boxing ring but lower to the ground. Using a series of projectors located directly on the ceiling facing down, a unique view of the game from above was projected on the floor in the midst of the competitors. Spell effects that players would use in the games would cascade like fireworks across the stage floor in the rough location where they were happening in the game. The recent Blizzcon <em>Hearthstone</em> tournament had an elaborate stage set for the players that recreated the wood paneled and warmly torch-lit fantasy inn in <em>World of Warcraft</em> where the game takes place.</p> <p>But perhaps most astounding is the Blizzcon <em>StarCraft</em> stage, which is a 130 foot long 40 foot high sculptural space that uses 24 synced projectors to run an elaborate projection map system during games. Projection mapping is the sophisticated technique where computer software is used to warp and bend two dimensional imagery so that it is possible to seamlessly project on to three dimensional objects to make those objects appear animated. The <em>StarCraft</em> stage is a marvel of digital technology, featuring a constantly shifting swarm of different in-game screens, video feeds, computer effects animations, and elements from the game, as well as housing the booths for the players. The fusion of these sorts of advanced 3D hybrid-reality technologies and video games, which are all run on sophisticated 3D modeling systems anyway, are one of the most exciting potential areas for exploration for future esports live events.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/5_8.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/5_8.jpg?itok=Vmy7Nc0L" width="700" height="344" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Uh, Let’s Go To A 30 Minute Commercial Break!</strong></p> <p>Owing to the structure of professional play, one of the great challenges for broadcasting MOBAs as sports is that the length of any given series can vary wildly. <em>Dota2</em> has by far the most variable game lengths. Games can be so short that drafting picks and bans can last longer than some individual games. In fact, a game at last year’s International 4 clocked in at merely 14 minutes and 37 seconds. Games can just as easily become a stalemate. For instance, one 2015 game between the teams Cloud 9 and SFZ broke all records when it clocked in at 3 hours, 20 minutes, and 34 seconds! Considering that most tournament matches are played as best of threes or fives, a complete 3-0 stomp can be over before the casters get to talk through the players’ bios (and leave live audiences disappointed), while a drawn out match that goes to the fifth game can see the casters losing their voices. In fact, a few esports matches have run so long that the venue closed down before all the games were played and the audience was kicked out while the players were left to finish the match in an empty room.</p> <p>Early on, <em>LoL</em> game times used to be quite variable. There was even a phase in the twilight mists of yore where certain European teams figured out that the best way to win was to stall every game well past the hour mark to fatigue their opponents. In response to these scenarios and other, Riot has very actively tuned elements of modern <em>LoL</em> to make game times both shorter and more stable. Most game times follow a bell curve peaking at right around 35 minutes. The shortest game in the recently concluded League Championship System (LCS) Worlds Finals was 23:49 long (CLG vs. Koo Tigers) and the longest came in just shy of an hour at 55:27 (TSM vs Origen). Even with more stable game times, even tightly controlled MOBAs like <em>LoL</em> can struggle to retain consistent engagement for a viewer because the act of closing out the game by breaking the opposing team’s base often becomes pro-forma but time consuming. Caster Montecristo (who plays the villain character on the Worlds analyst desk) has been known to correctly declare a game “over” as early as four minutes based solely on a single blunder.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/11_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/11_1.jpg?itok=vFpQBqFH" width="700" height="407" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>HotS</em> has the unique position of being designed during the time when the early MOBAs were already coming into the mainstream. So even though the large pool of maps all have different systems and strategies for winning and hence should have quite variable game length, Blizzard has introduced numerous elements, from ramping character lethality to objectives that have an ever-increasing potency, to make sure games tend to finish at no longer than half an hour. This is all in accordance with the Blizzard designers’ stated intent to create a game that wouldn’t stagnate. In <em>HotS</em>, if a team has a clear advantage they should be able to push to finish the game quickly, while the only games that tend to run long are between teams that are evenly matched and tend to also be the most action packed for a viewer.</p> <p>Comebacks, the great lifeblood of sports casting, happen but infrequently in MOBAs. This sense of smothering inevitability coupled with long game times greatly contributes to the challenges of presenting a consistently entertaining broadcast of MOBA matches. As I discussed in part 4 of this series (<a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">“A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield”</a> ) all three top MOBAs have systems that exponentially reward winning teams and punish losing teams. This is most clearly highlighted by the statistic that the team that takes the first inhibitor in <em>LoL</em> has upwards of a 85% likelihood to win (as high as 100% for some tournaments like the 2014 All Stars). In <em>Dota2</em>, for The International 3, the first team to destroy a barracks had a 96.36% chance to win the game. Though it is worth keeping in mind the caveat that <em>Dota2</em> pro play has the unique aspect that games typically end in a surrender, so in many ways taking a racks is usually viewed as the end-game. Teams almost never surrender in <em>LoL</em> though it is technically possible, with surrendering being considered either a sign of a total mental collapse of a team or that they felt cheated by the outcome. In <em>HotS</em>, because of how the game is designed to snowball the leading team to victory, there is no surrender option, just a mercifully short crushing under the heels of some ten story tall magic-powered skeleton or the like.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/6_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/6_5.jpg?itok=lNeetlwn" width="700" height="353" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>This Bud’s For Team Solo Mid Hyper X</strong></p> <p>One burgeoning aspect of esports is their relationship to sports bars and sports drinking culture. The first esports/gaming bar just opened in Paris, called Meltdown, but events known as BarCrafts have been a part of the esports world through <em>StarCraft</em> for quite some time. Basically, a BarCraft is when a group of avid <em>StarCraft</em> fans organize a takeover of a local sports bar and convince the bar to play the stream of a major tournament over the TVs. Usually these are quite elaborate events, filled with raffles, costumes, theme drinks, and sponsored giveaways. These events tend to happen in major cities or near large universities and became one of the primary ways to originally experience esports live since the tournaments were usually hosted in Korea.</p> <p>The MOBA world has continued the tradition of these pun-named events with PubStomps (the name is a pun on a slang term for higher level players crushing novice players in a random “PUBlic” match). <em>Dota2</em>’s slightly older fanbase tends to be the foremost continuers of this tradition, and Valve pushes fans to host these events especially during their biggest tournament, The International. Recent International websites have included a list of PubStomps and broadcasts have even aired live clips from PubStomps around the world as filler. That said, there are very few of these PubStomp events since the only other company sponsored tournament happens in China during very inconvenient, or downright illegal, hours for a bar to be open.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">No one, not the farmers, high school teachers, construction workers, or local lawyers that frequent that bar paid any mind that a video game competition was playing instead of a traditional sport. </div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>LoL</em> traditionally has a younger fan base, so Riot has publicly encouraged fans to band together for “viewing parties” which are then listed on the LCS site, and can vary from small living rooms filled with a few friends to thousands of people gathering in college recreation centers. <em>HotS</em> didn’t have a large enough tournament for this sort of event to happen until Blizzcon this year which drew away most of the fans who would have otherwise gone to a BarCraft style event. But given Blizzard’s support for these events in the past, such sending as staff to make guest appearances or lots of merchandise to give out at BarCrafts, it seems likely they will continue to encourage fans to raid the local pub and watch their favorite game while pounding a few pints. While these rare specialty events have been the standard way for fans to gather to watch esports in the past, as the age of these first generation of MOBA players rises alongside the public acceptance of video games, it will be curious to see if there will be more public viewing of these events. This is especially true given that sports mega-broadcaster ESPN has shown great interest in broadcasting this material on traditional cable channels.</p> <p>In fact this Fall I was visiting the rural Midwest for a family wedding and when I popped in to the local bar, ESPN’s coverage of the International 5 was spread over the dozen massive flat screen televisions that is seemingly a prerequisite for any bar in America these days. No one, not the farmers, high school teachers, construction workers, or local lawyers that frequent that bar paid any mind that a video game competition was playing instead of a traditional sport. Though when I asked the bartender if there was any special reason it was on, she accidentally answered with a nonchalant portent of the future. They simply always leave the TV on ESPN.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/7_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/7_3.jpg?itok=AVQCSi-N" width="700" height="467" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Economics : A Linage Of Gold and Play</strong></p> <p>Historically the video game market, rife with tech sector optimism, has often behaved as though any trend can only go up. While the rise of esports to public consciousness has been astoundingly fast, as the swath of failed and canceled Massive Multiplayer Online (MMO) games that companies developed to cash in on the unprecedented success of <em>World of Warcraft</em> indicates, the future of other MOBAs to gain any market share is deeply uncertain. <em>Smite</em>, a novel First Person Shooter (FPS) MOBA hybrid has been around for almost as long as <em>LoL</em> and while <em>Smite</em> is the fourth most popular MOBA, it only has a paltry 2.5% market share and has tournaments’ stream viewers that number below ten thousand. The recent cancelations of Electronic Arts’ MOBA <em>Dawngate</em> and Turbine DC’s superhero themed MOBA <em>Infinite Crisis</em> have shown just how hard it is for even top video game companies with strong licenses to make a successful foray into the esports world.</p> <p>Though massive amounts of money are being spent to follow the MOBA trend, a critical lesson to remember is that the whole MOBA genre was started by fans making a totally new game out of tools from <em>Warcraft 3</em>. This sort of bedroom evolution is similar to the way that playground games will inevitably develop as long as there is a field and some players. One other historical note that highlights the idea that trends in esports evolve with collaboration from fans is that despite Microsoft, Sony, and Infinity ward constantly pouring money into promoting <em>Call of Duty</em> as an esport, it is vastly superseded by the nigh-ancient in game terms (1999) FPS <em>Counter-Strike</em>, which itself was started as a mod for <em>Half-Life</em>. One area of potential organic growth is in the still unexplored area of tablet-based esports, though the first steps seem to have been charted by Blizzard’s <em>Hearthstone</em> online collectable card game. Interest in the <em>Hearthstone</em> professional leagues has already vastly overshadowed <em>HotS</em> so perhaps this suggests that yet more models of esports will evolve from the new technologies gaining a foothold in our lives.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/8_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/8_4.jpg?itok=kc1JeZpA" width="700" height="369" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Taming the Wild West</strong></p> <p>It’s worthwhile to mention that with all of this money swirling around MOBAs and esports, the inevitable dark side of professional sports comes right along into the virtual world. Cheating has already happened at even the highest levels of these games. Memorably, Korean team Azubu Frost, in the 2012 <em>LoL</em> World Finals became permanent villains for watching the production screens during a match to see where their opponents were. Though that was at least partially Riot’s fault for putting screens in such a way as to be optimal for the audience, but where players could see them on stage. There have been a number of high profile cases where investment was gathered to build a major esports team and then the management absconds with the cash leaving the players and investors high and dry. There have also been a number of high-profile match fixing cases and cases where players have thrown games after betting against themselves in gray-market betting sites. In fact, in one extremely troubling case a professional Chinese <em>LoL</em> player tried to commit suicide after the organization pressured him to fix matches.</p> <p>The sloppy, egotistical, and sometimes downright offensive public behavior of athletes has also become a problem. Doubly so in esports because in most cases the Western players have not had any sort of mentor or coach to teach them sportsmanship or proper empathic adult behavior. This has included high profile <em>LoL</em> players being banned after making accounts with racist names while visiting countries for tournaments, and pro players getting year-long suspensions for regularly using homophobic, transphobic, and racist language in games. A top tier LCS player was recently suspended for selling fully unlocked tournament accounts (which are only given to LCS players) on the black market. One major <em>StarCraft</em> player was suspended for watching webcam performances of an underage girl and posting lewd comments about it.</p> <p>Doping has recently become an issue of note, though how extensive it actually is (or even effective) remains an open question. Recenty the use of Adderall, which is also a common “study-drug” on American college campuses, for focus has been alleged in various Kotaku articles. All leagues have explicit bans on performance enhancing substances but no league or company has any system of testing in place so the exact details of these suspicions remain hidden and based solely on player admissions. But given that millions and millions of dollars of prize money are on the line, and players are earning salaries on par with other major sports where doping is extremely common, taking an easily available low-side-effect Ativan for nerves or Adderall for focus before going on stage in front of 100,000 screaming fans seems rather plausible. As the infrastructure for esports starts to become embedded in colleges and in law, such as the US and Korean eSports visa specifications, all of these issues will have to be addressed sooner rather than later since these large social institutions have vastly more rules and expectations than the wild West of the purely online space in which esports arose.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/9_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/9_2.jpg?itok=kCferHP8" width="700" height="438" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Pay-To-Win (At Having More Sparkles) [For Now…]</strong></p> <p>One of the other most popular up-and-coming esports style games is Wargaming’s <em>World of Tanks</em> (alongside its innumerable other World of War-Nouns brethren) but its business model brings up a very troubling prospect for future esports companies, which is the fretted about notion of “pay to win.” In <em>World of Tanks/Warships/Warplanes</em>, you play as said vehicle which can be bought in a similar manner to the three MOBAs, which is through either in-game currency or through real money. But in the <em>World of…</em> games there are various “premium” ammunitions, consumables, and even special vehicles that can only be purchased for real money. In fact, with premium ammunition, you pay a certain small amount of money per shot in a match to get a better shell to fire than someone not paying real money per shot. This sort of insidious “pay to win” aspect is unfortunately part of mobile gaming’s ever more occult attempt to harpoon their “whales” (as they call people who spend insane sums of money on a game), which makes Wargaming’s embrace of the concept on PC and console in a competitive esport environment even more troubling.</p> <p>“Pay to win” is but one obvious facet of the troubles that can arise from a single company controlling all aspects of a sport, including the very legal holding of the game itself, in the hands of one company much more subtle abuses are possible. Why these sorts of conflicts of interest are so troubling in esports might take some additional explaining. In the case of traditional sports like baseball or football, no one owns the underlying game itself. That is, no one owns the idea of two guys beating each other up, even if they own the name “Ultimate Fighting Championship.” If UFC does a terrible job and constantly cheats its fans and players, then goes bankrupt, another organization could easily arise. Players can still go to a gym and have a match in front of the local fans. If Major League Baseball went under, parents could still throw the ball around with their child. But if TenCent, the massive for-profit Chinese company who owns Riot Games, closes <em>LoL</em>, they own that property and no one could play <em>LoL</em>. Not only that, but because of patent law, basic mechanical and stylistic elements can be copyrighted or patented and could not be used by anyone else. This is a very real possibility considering that Riot bought a huge swath of patents pertaining to MOBAs and esports. They claimed that they were doing it in an altruistic way with the hopes that patent law would be changed for the better, but they are under no legal obligation to remain altruistic. For example <em>Magic: the Gathering</em>’s parent company Wizards of the Coast owned patents on rudimentary game elements like turning a card to the side to show that it is used. These patents were transferred to board game giant Hasbro when Wizards of the Coast was bought and has been strictly enforced to squash competition from small collectable card game companies. In the case of esports, the game companies also administer the esports rules, pay players, and craft the game balance, all while first and foremost being a for-profit company trying to make money for their investors.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">“Pay to win” is but one obvious facet of the troubles that can arise - much more subtle abuses are possible. </div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>While everyone is currently excited to see video game competitions on ESPN, the clear conflict of interest hides in this assumption of benevolence. Nothing prevents a company who has spent the better decade making a very fair, fun game, to suddenly get sold and start imposing draconian rules for players. For instance, right now there is already significant grumbling amongst the <em>LoL</em> fans because it is hard to tell if it is it a coincidence or manipulation that TenCent/Riot launched a new real-money-only skin for the character Darius at the exact same time he was rebalanced to be one of the strongest characters in game. This combination of rebalance plus premium purchasable item is common in video games, but this case is troubling because it also happened to be right before the biggest tournament of the year, Worlds, where all the best top laners would now need to use that character.</p> <p>These players are almost all on the payroll of Riot, and all also just happened to almost exclusively use that skin which the casters, also on Riot’s payroll, regularly talked about as being the best skin. Whether this was coincidence, good marketing, or a cynical financial decision that drastically affected the outcome of the most critical tournament of the year, is extremely hard to discern and that very opaqueness becomes a major stumbling block for the long-term future of esports.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/10_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/10_2.jpg?itok=gSAv4RGA" width="700" height="507" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Given the problems with the way the video game market tends to bunch up at the top with one or two dominant properties in each genre, and with the clear conflict of interest between game companies and fair sporting practices, perhaps new models might arise around the margins in the same way that the MOBA genre was created by fans. For instance, at the recent IndieCade esports panel, developer Winnie Song mentioned that in some ways the Olympics, with their pluralistic collation of games, from gymnastics to basketball, from shooting to skateboarding, might be a more useful model for esports than the monolithic Western single-sport stylings. This federation of games and competition, with its regular changing cohort of games (they are even thinking of adding ultimate frisbee!) presents other issues. Aside from the sheer difficulty of organizing any large scale of Olympic style video game events, which the World Cyber Games has found out, such widely spread mega-events have to contend with the very real relationship between economic stability and peak performance, such as the difficulties of being a full time player that came up our examination of the difficulties of DotA 2’s tournament structure. Additionally, what will happen when esports become normalized in culture? Will esports still be a special genre, or just another mandatory massive cost on game companies who want to make multiplayer games? What happens when there are so many esports broadcasts that they reach saturation much like podcasts now, when consumers can no longer even begin to consume all the content they wish to? Will these esports, formerly such radical and exciting accidental mutations of the digital fringes, simply become another conservative interchangeable entertainment default option to shovel advertising to a lucrative target demographic of consumer-fans? It will be interesting to see how all this esports boom evolves alongside the boom of other non-traditional sports broadcasting such as MMA, <em>Magic: the Gathering</em>, the various reality shows about real life ninjas, and the massive but totally unexpected rise of poker in America. In fact, at the 2015 Blizzcon, two world renowned professional poker players (one of whom is a former pro <em>StarCraft</em> player) are going to be doing a show match for <em>Hearthstone</em>, bridging the ever-narrowing gap between many new burgeoning sporting and gaming cultures.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>A Few Words in Conclusion</strong></p> <p>Within and around MOBAs and esports there are innumerable intriguing places to start thinking about modern society, potential new modes for art production, and the ways that the performative aspects of esports are changing our cultures’ relationships to video games in drastic ways.</p> <p>I spent the better part of my gaming time for about four years deeply involved with MOBAs and esports, particularly in <em>LoL</em>, and all of the experiences, both positive and negative, were the inspiration for thinking about video games and their intersection with the social labor of hobbies and infrastructure of fandoms. As such, much of this article is observational, speculation, and free-association, though every intention was made to double check any factual information and data when possible. Also important to note is that because these games are under constant revision I kept a bit of a broad lens to try to make this writing useful no matter how many post-season patches Riot pushes through. But some details will assuredly be inaccurate within moments of publication. In fact, in the middle of writing this <em>HotS</em> went from closed beta to announced date, to live, and from having a few informal tournaments to a massive organized global event. So inevitably there will be quibbles and inaccuracies but these very moments of slippage are hopefully still useful as a time capsule of this moment in esports.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">MOBAs are like any other living sports in their first generations, evolving, modifying themselves, and adopting new goals and social norms faster than observers can notice</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>These MOBAs are like any other living sports in their first generations, evolving, modifying themselves, and adopting new goals and social norms faster than observers can notice. To close with a reflection on historical perspective, the defining feature of American football, the forward pass, was only introduced in 1906. The game had been played publicly since the 1820’s, which means that the current most defining trait of the one of the most watched sports took almost 90 years to evolve! Lest we get caught up in the futurism of esports right now, the first major publicly broadcast esport, <em>StarCraft: Brood Wars</em> came out in 1998, and the game that all of these MOBAs are based on, <em>Warcraft 3</em>, came out in 2003. That means we’re a scant 17 years along the timeline of these sorts of sports. Doing some (slightly facetious) napkin math, that means the “forward pass of MOBAs” will show up some time around 73 years, or the year 2088. Until then, who knows what curious games, broadcasts, and digital hybrids will rise and fall - but I do know I’ll probably still be watching from the sidelines with great interest.</p> <hr> <p><em>This article was only made possible by the support and engagement of the community of awesome, engaged, people around me. Thanks to Rainer and Video Game Tourism for agreeing to take a chance and run this series even though there was very little precedent for what I was trying to do (and I barely had more than a hunch that esports might be interesting to a critical and arts audience)! Massive thanks to Callie, who not only put up with my constant esports banter around the house, but who also served as copy editor for this whole series and as such basically made this whole thing legible for you all to read. Thanks to Jason and Sam for both constantly being willing to work through my half-crazed ideas and for always sharing their immense wisdom both for how game design and the industry actually works (or doesn’t).</em></p> <p><em>Special thanks to Will for being constantly grounding my observations by forever being able to connect them to a wealth of historical knowledge about seemingly every other sport that has existed (choose him for your trivia team). Also, I really want to mention how much the various people affiliated with my Sunday night gaming group contributed to this piece, both for letting me talk out my ideas but also for having innumerable savvy suggestions and concerns about the future of esports. Sometimes it’s hard to talk while playing, but we got there eventually! Thanks to all the various friends at game companies involved in MOBA and RTS production who downed copious beers and talked with me on and off the record about their passion for esports. Though I’m not the best player, all those late night conversations helped build a context for my investigation. Thanks to IndieCade and games curator Chloe Lister for the fantastic indie esports panel discussion which helped open up some interesting new ways of thinking about what constitutes an esport. Thanks the folks who run the L.A. and Irvine BarCrafts for being so enthusiastic introducing a total noob like me to the wider world of esports culture.</em></p> <p><em>If you shared any of these articles, offered corrections, or even just read the pieces, thanks so much! Finally, thanks to Christine and Eric from Southland Ensemble for inviting me to do the art show “Learned and Lost” in Los Angeles this Spring which was really the impetus for all of this further research about why esports and MOBAs are such a curious and potent part of contemporary culture.</em></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> </ul> </div> Wed, 18 Nov 2015 08:48:11 +0000 Eron Rauch 638 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - The Grand Spectacle https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle <span>Demystifying MOBAs - The Grand Spectacle</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_5.jpg?itok=wOYJYRQ_" width="700" height="200" alt title="Michael T. McGreevey and players of the amateur baseball team that he sponsored, the Nuf Ceds, 1910. Boston Public Library."> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-10-29T13:33:21+01:00" title="Donnerstag, 29 Oktober 2015 - 13:33">Do. 29 Okt 2015 - 13:33</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs. This is part 7.</em></p> <p>With the explosive rise of Valve’s <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (<em>DotA2</em>), Riot’s <em>League of Legends</em> (<em>LoL</em>), and Blizzard’s <em>Heroes of the Storm</em> (<em>HotS</em>), the mainstream media seems to be quite deeply perplexed by the claim that video games could be a sport. It is incredibly rare to be present in the earliest days of any cultural phenomena, but similar to seeing the supporting structure of a half-finished building. This primordial vantage point is immensely interesting because it provides a clear view of how culture is constructed both in fans and from the sporting organizations. In fact, getting to watch this process of a professional sport that is only a decade old (via <em>StarCraft</em>) trying to legitimize itself highlights the artifice and art of all sporting events. As esports are still uncharted territory, each game company has made distinct choices with their experiments in trying to promote, share, professionalize, and define their game as an esport.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/rol-uMGhj4w" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rol-uMGhj4w" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rol-uMGhj4w</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>Video: Stephen Dean’s “VOLTA” is an art piece exploring the elaborate and specific fan displays that have evolved at football games.</em></p> <p><strong>The Grand Spectacle Part 1: The More Zeroes The Merrier</strong></p> <p>To start our conversation, let’s look at DotA2, which only has an estimated 14% market share of the moba industry but draws the most attention from mainstream media.<br> (<em>Corrected on 10/19/2015 to reflect current industry statistics that DotA2 is the second most played moba not third.)</em> This is primarily because of its massive prize pools for its top event, The International. The winnings topped ten million U.S. dollars for the victorious team this year, which about two million dollars gross per winning player. But there are only two tournaments this size sponsored by <em>DotA2</em>’s parent company each year, The International which is held in America and <em>DotA</em> Asia Championship which is held in China but which only has about a quarter of the prize pool. The rest of the year is filled with a chaotic schedule of smaller regional and online events produced by other organizations. Curiously, the way that Valve creates these giant prize pools for their two huge tournaments is by crowd-funding. To do this, Valve sells and then gives a portion of the profit to the prize pool from a specific in-game item called a “Compendium.” They are basically interactive versions of the programs sold at big sports games or concerts. These digital books, which are accessed in the game client, are filled with information about the teams but also as a raffle-ticket-like system for getting special in-game items. Which means many players buy multiple copies of these virtual programs in the hope of getting rare skins for their characters. The Compendium is also an elaborate interactive fantasy sports prediction system that rewards players for making correct predictions about all manner of potential statistics, from major events such as predicting the winner of whole tournament to the tiniest details such as what the length of the shortest game will be. The more of these items <em>DotA2</em> players buy, the more funds go in to the prize pool.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/1_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/1_5.jpg?itok=IGrxXXKf" width="700" height="375" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Much like the Olympics, even the largest teams tend to focus their efforts around these massive tournaments, with roster changes almost inevitable between events based on success or failure. Teams that win more than predicted stay together, teams that lose faster than expected tend to get fired or break up. <em>DotA2</em> teams are independent of Valve, though they are usually affiliated with a larger esports sponsor or clan organization such as Cloud 9 which has top-tier teams in <em>DotA2</em>, <em>LoL</em>, and <em>HotS</em>. The largest sponsored teams sometimes pay their players a salary and especially well-known players can make six digits just from team pay each year.</p> <p>It is still relatively rare for <em>DotA2</em> teams to live together except for a month of boot camp before major events. All but the largest teams are run like local or amateur sports organizations and the players have to fund their own expenses. The setup for professional <em>DotA2</em> teams is fairly mercenary even in the bigger teams, where the organization usually pays for travel expenses for their team but in return asks for part of the tournament prize pool winnings, usually 50 %. Because of this volatility and because so much of the prize money is tied up at the top end of infrequent mega-matches it has traditionally been quite challenging for <em>DotA</em> players to make a living at the game with only the very upper echelon being able to pursue the game full time.</p> <p><strong>The Grand Spectacle Part 2: Dolla Dolla Bills LoL</strong></p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">The concept of 'gaming house' originates in Korean telecom teams, as does the tradition of providing extensive coaching and trainers.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>LoL</em>’s professional play has evolved through many iterations before it landed on what is now called the League Championship System (LCS). The LCS was specifically designed to mitigate many of the volatility issues that affected the professional players in the <em>DotA</em> community. Riot organizes regional leagues, where 10 teams are paired off on a set schedule and play every weekend for a series of seasons, which cumulates in a playoff every few months. Then at the end of the year, the three most successful teams compete in a World Championship tournament with a top prize pool of a million dollars. Most critically, in the American and the EU circuits, Riot pays the players on the teams a salary regardless of their team organization’s salary. All ten teams in both leagues currently are affiliated with both major brand sponsorship and a gaming organization which pay for players based on their status and provide a house for the team to live and practice in all year (located near Los Angeles in the case of American <em>LoL</em> and near Berlin for the EU).</p> <p>While Riot pays player salaries in the West, the main difference with Korean <em>LoL</em> is that because there are long-established professional teams from era of <em>StarCraft</em> sponsored around telecom and entertainment companies, the teams take the lead in paying and organizing players. The concept of the gaming house originates in these Korean telecom teams, as does the tradition of providing extensive coaching and trainers in exchange for a cut of the winnings. The other other major <em>LoL</em> esports scene, China, has the same weekly match schedule but the teams are mostly funded by a combination of sponsor and private investment money. This combination is often considered one of the reasons that the Chinese <em>DotA</em> and now <em>LoL</em> community is so competitive. Namely, that teams have a tradition of offering massive salaries to lure away top players from competitors.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/2_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/2_5.jpg?itok=mzfYyoLt" width="700" height="434" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Historically one of the major differences between the early esports scene in the West versus Korea was that before Riot’s implementation of the LCS, most Western players and teams made their income through streaming live video for fans to watch on websites such as Twitch, whereas in Korea players were housed and paid by their team to practice full time. This factor has been regarded as a large part of why the Korean and Chinese teams have been dominant even though they have been playing the game for years less than the American and EU teams. The logic is as follows: most Western professional players, because they paid their bills from Twitch and YouTube streaming, are then actually having to function as celebrity entertainers first and professional athletes only as secondary function.</p> <p>Team SoloMid (TSM) is possibly the most extraordinary example of this tendency, existing foremost as a bro-centric lifestyle brand (with the slogan “Bay Life”) that has their <em>LoL</em> team as part of a large media operation. TSM’s mid laner Andy Dinh is also the brand owner, and retired at the top of his game to take over full time business operations. They even went as far as having their players film an online reality show during actual LCS seasons. In fact, many of the people making the most money in the Western <em>LoL</em> scene aren’t even on a professional team. In Europe, Carlos “Ocelote” Santiago, who was the mid laner for SK Gaming but does not play professionally anymore, is known as the richest esports athlete. But his wealth is primarily earned from his website’s shop, which exceeds 500,000 euros each year in sales of branded products. Since so many of the top Western players came from this era of self funding, it took a while for players and teams to adjust to being part of a large, stable, organization. Even though <em>LoL</em> has been a major esport since 2011, it wasn’t until 2015 that teams started copying Korean models and getting houses for practice and hiring coaching staff. Much like traditional sports, owning teams has become a mark of status for young investors and technocrats in both in China and America, with even disgraced price-gouging pharmaceutical investor Martin Shkreli serving as chairman for Team Imagine (which ultimately failed in it’s bid to make the LCS.)</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">What if the bottom two foorball or baseball clubs of every region could be challenged by all comers for their spot in the league?</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>With this in mind, the monetary decisions can often actually discourage players from going pro or even to dedicate time to practicing correctly. <em>StarCraft</em>’s Korean scene makes this distinction between professional athlete and entertainer most clear. Players in Korean teams often have a massive advantage over Western players simply because Western players get so much of their paycheck through streaming that they have to be online and playing publicly for everyone to analyze all the time. While Koreans have their food and housing paid for by their team, and thus can hide their practice sessions before important matches without fear of failing to pay rent. Additionally, teams in Korea can fire and hire players without the same pressure to keep their brand making money from well-known but possibly past prime celebrity players, giving them a massive competitive edge in global matches. Although the rather ruthless way Korean teams manage players, including banning girlfriends and imposing strict curfews, has helped lead to the rise of Chinese <em>LoL</em>, since the tech investors and their exorbitant salaries come with few rules. The Korean scene is so focused on winning that while Western players like Ocelote often rely on their internet celebrity for their income, in Korea it is common practice for top teams to disallow players from even having Twitter accounts until they “earned it” by winning a tournament! In order to combat some of the forces that drive teams toward celebrity and not professional gameplay in the Western scene, the LCS system has one major deviation from traditional sports leagues.</p> <p>At the end of every season, the bottom two teams in the standings have to play the top two teams from an amateur tournament, called Challenger League, and if they lose, they have to give their spot in the LCS to the victorious team. To get their sport back the failed team has to survive grueling, unpublicized months in amateur scene to regain their spot in the LCS. Often being relegated from the LCS leads to teams disbanding or having both their players and sponsors replaced completely. Imagine how that would play out in the realms of professional baseball or football if the bottom two clubs of every region could be challenged by all comers for their spot!</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/3_6.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/3_6.jpg?itok=ONMf4ft6" width="700" height="473" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Grand Spectacle Part 3: Blizzcon Madness</strong></p> <p>Compared to any of the other major esports games, <em>HotS</em> is still in its infancy even though it has been live for months. Thus far Blizzard has shown a tendency toward two models they might speculatively use for professional play. The first is to serve as a backing organization while letting another company manage the esports broadcasts. The other is to directly interact with the community through sponsored major tournaments like in <em>DotA2</em>. In the past with <em>StarCraft</em> and <em>WarCraft</em> Blizzard has partnered behind the scenes with a third party esports organizations such as ESL (an online broadcasting brand) or GomTV (a Korean cable network) to run the ongoing league-style events. Even during the first few years of <em>Lo</em>L’s rise to be the king of eSports, the approaches of Riot and Blizzard could not have been more different. While Riot became known as the esports brand because they built an in-house studio and hired their own broadcast team to professionally produce events, Blizzard was actually spending more money on promoting esports each year but didn’t have their name on screen because they chose to keep sports production and video game design apart. After the success of <em>LoL</em>’s LCS Blizzard reorganized the fragmented professional <em>StarCraft 2</em> community into what is now called the WCS, which features weekly matches in a league sponsored and run by Blizzard, capping with a tournament at Blizzcon in California each year.</p> <p>The only other clue we have to Blizzard’s intentions for <em>HotS</em> as a sport is that they may be reaching for another traditional model, which is the NCAA college basketball tournament (called March Madness here in the US for all of the insane amount of attention and gambling it receives). Blizzard recently sponsored a tournament called “Heroes of the Dorm” which let 64 colleges field <em>HotS</em> teams in a bracket system very much like March Madness. A number of the best players even got hired to join top tier pro teams afterward. Currently Blizzard is maintaining a hybrid approach, partnering with ESL, the online gaming website and broadcasting brand owned by Turtle Entertainment, to run the broadcasts while using established Blizzard personalities from the <em>StarCraft</em> scene as the face of the tournament. ESL handles the weekly matches, and Blizzard still gets to have their name at the top of the billing for the final global tournament. In many ways, thinking about how disorganized and amateur the early days of any popular sport like baseball or football were highlights how the formation of professional leagues, tournament structures, and public performances is a critical part to how societies categorize the difference between sport, game, and hobby.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/4_6.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/4_6.jpg?itok=RWs2sSrK" width="700" height="447" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Ahhhhhh, The Passion of [Male] Youth</strong></p> <p>If you were to watch any MOBA esports, two things would stand out immediately about the players and fans. First, almost everyone from casters to staff members to fans to players are really young. Second, they are almost all male. Historically because of the Korean government’s active hand in promoting esports as a way to show the world how technologically advanced they were, players of games like <em>StarCraft</em> have been recruited extremely young. Like the Russian ballet and gymnastics, the Korean esports world has systems in place to identify talent while they are still in elementary school and place them with trainers and teams as early as junior high, giving them exemptions and modified schedules for school. It is not uncommon for 14 year olds to live in a team house and play professionally, though most of the top players really start to reach full potential at 16.</p> <p>Starting as an American and European game at first, <em>LoL</em>’s original cast of professional players were college age, since that was the first time most players could devote the requisite hours to streaming to pay bills to be full time gamers and also to have the scheduling freedom from to practice with their teams. When the LCS initially formed, paying sizable salaries to pro players, most of the teams had very little infrastructure in place to support an influx of high profile professional athletes. Teams were often just the five young guys living in a nearly bare house. In fact, in many cases it the first time most of the players had been put in a situation where they were living on their own. Expected to play 12 hours a day, but given no other parameters or role models, predictable problems occurred. There were even some notorious moments of total public drunkenness, verbal tirades, and collapses from lack of sleep and proper nutrition during professional games. As teams gained stability, coaches and trainers were hired, and physical conditioning was emphasized, but the bro-ish standard of behavior that comes with the frat-house manner of gaming houses was already enshrined in the Western scene.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Owing to the new expectation that all players on a team should live in the same house, practice constantly, and with most players being around 19-20 years old, players are rarely are part of a stable relationship. In fact, there have been almost no married pro esports players. Even having a girlfriend is generally considered nearly impossible to balance with playing professionally, since there was historically no off season until Riot decided to implement big changes after the worldwide tournament last year. During the earliest days of <em>LoL</em> when teams didn’t have houses, Alex “Alex Ich” Ichetovkin (currently age 23) was wildly considered one of the best mid laners, and was married. But his team eventually disbanded partially owing to the birth of his first child preventing him from living in a team house. Additionally, a member of Complexity Black, Bubbadub, the only <em>LoL</em> player to have a mustache according to his Gameipedia page if that tells you anything about the average age of the players, was married and quit his job to play professionally for a season. But even he had to live apart from his wife with his team for the year he played pro. He’s now a very successful coach, which alongside caster, is the usual job for former pro players who want to stay in the business.</p> <p>Surprisingly, even though the average age of <em>DotA2</em> players are much higher and their schedules more flexible since they rarely live in team houses, only one top tier pro is married, Xiao8 from the superstar Chinese team LGD. He has always had the reputation as a superstar and man-about-town, and was rumored to have made as much as six million dollars a year during his heyday. Speculation was rife from the moment of the announcement that marriage meant he was retiring, and sure enough a few months later he quit playing professionally. As a small side note, the age that is considered standard retirement for esports players, 28, is not as arbitrary as it seems. It actually comes from the fact that 28 is the last year Koreans can go and complete their two year mandatory military service, so pro players defer their service as long as they are playing well and then retire to serve their term, since returning after two years in such rapidly changing games is nigh impossible.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/5_6.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/5_6.jpg?itok=w6kBTK6o" width="700" height="298" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Alongside the lack of married players, out of the hundreds of professional teams between all three games there are only a half-dozen female players who have ever even been part of a professional team and none that have started a top tier professional game. As self-reported by Riot “over 90%” of <em>LoL</em>’s player base is male. Possibly sensing that over 50% of the gaming public is being left financially untapped, but also in line with their stated goals of trying to make their community less toxic, in 2015 Riot has been trying to hire at least a few female analysts and casters to be public faces for the esports side of the game. But all one has to do is watch Twitch chat to see the massive levels of general abuse, sexualization, and harassment the pioneering Riot-employed analysts like Devin “Froskurinn” Ryan Mohr (also the former coach of a professional Chinese team, Roar) or Eefje “sjokz” Depoortere still regularly receive. One note is that some colleges in the US have agreed to start having scholarship-based <em>LoL</em> and <em>DotA2</em> teams. This is particularly interesting because there is a law in the United States called Title IX which as it is currently read mandates educational institutions have to provide equal sporting opportunity to all sexes (though with the way male sports still dominate campus life Title IX is hardly a panacea but it has vastly improved women’s access to professional teams). To me, it is absolutely clear that this boys’ club mentality both in the game art and in professional esports is the one remaining significant stumbling block to the final assertion of esports into broader cultural acceptance. The reason that MOBAs are a key part of this is because they dominate the conversation about esports.</p> <p>If unchecked, the incredibly toxic and bro-ish tendencies of the MOBA community could potentially taint the entire idea of how people perceive esports. The problems women face have been well discussed elsewhere and I highly recommend reading these accounts for a fuller picture of what is at stake. Polygon’s Emily Gera has covered the implications of how this issue affects the long term prospects of esports at <a href="http://www.polygon.com/2014/5/27/5723446/women-in-esports-professional-gaming-riot-games-blizzard-starcraft-lol">Polygon</a>. PC Gamer’s Christopher Livingston reported on a panel discussion of women in esports that tackled amongst other thing, <a href="http://www.pcgamer.com/gdc-panel-women-in-esports-are-walking-through-a-minefield/">the topic of female-only leagues</a>. At <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/31/esports-how-to-get-more-women-into-pro-gaming">The Guardian</a>, Philippa Ware looks at some strategies to bring more women in to esports. But the question still lingers if fans of MOBAs, esports professionals, and the video game production companies will chose to make their communities hospitable to women.</p> <p><em>Next week, we’ll continue looking at the various trappings and histories of esports broadcasting, including the way that the broadcasts turn abstract virtual games in to grand symbolic narratives.</em></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> </ul> </div> Thu, 29 Oct 2015 12:33:21 +0000 Eron Rauch 633 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - A History of Speed https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed <span>Demystifying MOBAs - A History of Speed</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_4.jpg?itok=v3iaamfq" width="700" height="200" alt title="Thomas Eakins’s painting of The Biglen Brothers Racing. Speed in 1873."> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-10-19T16:11:42+02:00" title="Montag, 19 Oktober 2015 - 16:11">Mo. 19 Okt 2015 - 16:11</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs. This is part 6.</em></p> <p>Last week’s Demystifying Mobas examined the ways that the resource gathering models of MOBAs highlight their differing ideas about balance and fairness. But to fully understand some of the curious complexities of why lightning fast mirco-games of precision and speed like last hitting, are not just prioritized, but even possible, it is critical to understand how MOBAs are a mutation from the Real Time Strategy (RTS) genre. <em>Warcraft 3</em> (by Blizzard Entertainment), which is the fantasy flavored brethren of <em>StarCraft</em> (also Blizzard), is the source for the entire MOBA genre.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>The original <em>DotA</em> was not a single game, but rather the most popular iteration of a style of <em>Warcraft 3</em> fan-made multi-player maps. All the assets, skills, and mechanics of the progenitor of the moba genre were made using pieces of <em>Warcraft 3</em> remixed in different ways. Every other MOBA game, including <em>LoL</em> and <em>HotS</em>, are variations and clones of <em>DotA</em> iterations. Because of this, MOBAs have inherited many obvious aspect from RTS games including 3/4 overhead view, many units which each have different skills that interact with each other, combat-centric interactions, and a large map that is played double-blind. A major difference is that RTS games are traditionally played as 1v1 in professional settings, which means one player controls a whole army, including all of the buildings, workers, and combat troops all at once in real time. Having a game system that can handle that massive series of player interactions at once as the underlying structure for MOBAs is one of the reasons the whole MOBA genre can seem so unfathomable but also why it has such massive amount of mechanical and strategic depth that keeps players engaged.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/1_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/1_4.jpg?itok=-I_nx-0o" width="700" height="362" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Real Time First, Strategy Last</strong></p> <p>Though “Strategy” would seem paramount given the formulation of the genre title, it’s vital to note that RTS games actually exhibit the opposite emphasis. It is the “Real Time” designation that is by far the most important element of RTS games. Mechanical mastery—raw precision and speed of using buttons and clicking a mouse—defines even the highest levels of play in these games, and as such was accidentally enshrined as a core aspect in MOBAs. To give a sense of just how fast RTS games are played, top <em>StarCraft</em> players can sustain 300-400 actions per minute during a game. That means 400 precisely coordinated keyboard presses and mouse clicks to direct units per minute (called APM), all without making a mistake, during games that can range upward of 45 minutes. For reference, a full-time professional typist will be maxing out at around 325 characters each minute. In fact, APM is so important in RTS games that any semblance of creative strategic decisions are mostly nonexistent until a player reaches complete intuitive technical mastery, which only happens at or above the the Grand Master (GM) level. Even GM level players often get there through highly prescribed and practiced game plans that bulldoze enemies through rehearsed speed. Think of it this way: if one player can click his soldiers to shoot at an enemy, but the other player can click to attack and also tell his base to make more soldiers in the same amount of time, the first [slower] player will fall exponentially ever further behind.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">In most games, additional amounts of input does not automatically equal better play. In MOBAs, speed became the primary marker of skill.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>But this design element wasn’t entirely intentional. One could easily imagine a world where strategy was prioritized over real time. In fact, if you listen to stories from players like Day9 about the earliest days of <em>StarCraft</em> (the first major esport), no one, not even the design team had any idea just how fast it would be possible for a player to play RTS games. After the games were out for a while, and players got more practiced and found more efficient ways to bind their keys and set up their mice (there is a 100-some page document on the Team Liquid site that talks about keyboard and mouse setups), play speeds kept going up in RTS games. In fact, a new player to <em>StarCraft</em> might only have 30 or 40 APM, and a good amateur who plays a lot might have an 80 APM average, so the game was tested and initially designed around those lower speeds. But once prestige and money was involved, and professional teams grew up to find and nurture players, an entirely new conception of the game started to evolve explicitly for these stratospheric heights of virtuosity. This might not seem like a big deal, but most curiously as more people got toward this unfathomable level of speed, they discovered that the game seemed to have no limit to the benefit of faster play because so much of a player’s APM was able to be used to generate resources and micromanage battles. Basically if someone could physically do it, the game would allow it.</p> <p>This seemingly banal “feature” is weird because in most games, additional amounts of input does not automatically equal better play. Wether it is <em>Mario</em> or <em>Street Fighter 5</em>, <em>Pac-Man</em> or <em>Call of Duty</em>, it is the precision of movement at a specific moment—in fact, it is economy of player input—that determines success. i.e. Pushing more buttons in <em>Street Fighter</em> to get more moves doesn’t equate to better play, in fact, it would leave your character perpetually out of position and open to counterattacks. Firing more shots in <em>Team Fortress 2</em> doesn’t make you a better player, in fact, it would mostly mean you were out of ammo from taking shots that were almost guaranteed to miss. Through the <em>StarCraft</em> expansion <em>Brood Wars</em>, which solidified the Korean obsession with esports and spawned the first cable channels dedicated to professional video game play, it became clear that the excitement such virtuosity brought was perfect for a television broadcast event. So speed became the primary marker of skill and the game was increasingly balanced and designed for on that near-infinite horizon.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/-yfMoIVTilo" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yfMoIVTilo" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yfMoIVTilo</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>Video: Notoriously fast StarCraft 2 player Losira.</em></p> <p>Lest I draw only parallels, it’s critical to note that the evolution of MOBAs and RTS games diverged immediately and deliberately. Even the early fan-made iterations of <em>DotA</em> were designed as a way for high level <em>Warcraft</em> players to relax and have fun between practice and matches. Instead of having to multitask 200 units, you’d just get one (or a few) units. Instead of each unit being some peon, with one or two abilities, you could play as the coolest hero characters in the game with spectacular attacks. Instead of managing a group of buildings for resources, the single character could gather them. Instead of playing by yourself, you could bring four friends. In fact, much of the success of both <em>LoL</em> and <em>HotS</em> can be correlated with their continuation of these trends toward individualizing the player and emphasizing team interaction. But while each of these differences changes where the complexity and conflict occurs in the game, the understructure of RTS mechanical play and game design still drastically affect what skills players need to have to be good. Though sustained APM is not as high in MOBAs as in RTS games, the average keyboard and mouse interactions at a professional level are still stunningly high, and wrist and hand injuries are common.</p> <p>Though the RTS scene was dominated by an arms race of raw clicking speed it quickly became clear that two other major elements separated the best players: multitasking and mastery of the double-blind vision mechanics. With hundreds of units to control across a large map, players who could multitask while paying attention in more places and interacting with more units at once had a massive edge since they could, in a simple scenario, defend against an attack but also counter attack their opponent at the same time. In more abstract terms, they could unitize their APM for more complex tactical decisions. This combination of speed and multitasking still defines the highest level of play in MOBAs. The most famous player in <em>LoL</em>, Faker, achieved his fame by being the first pro player to be able to simultaneously perfectly last hit minions while at the same time being able to maximize the amount of time spent attacking his lane opponent. Even other professionals say playing against Faker is like playing against two people because he has an uncanny ability to be able to see and respond to all aspects of the game at once, including moving his screen around to watch the rest of map and interact with his teammates as needed no matter where they are. It is interesting to note that due to the sheer levels of reflex speed and mental multitasking needed the average age for professional RTS players is very young. Even though <em>StarCraft 2</em> has made some moves to limit the effectiveness of ultra-high APMs (there is very little benefit for sustaining APMs above about 350) most players who are great start when they are in elementary school and retire in their early 20s.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/2_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/2_4.jpg?itok=uOexydCt" width="700" height="441" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Mechanics of Vision</strong></p> <p>That said, in RTS games both speed and multitasking can be taught the same way fundamentals are taught in any sport. With professional coaches and vast feeder systems similar to sports drafting, it became clear that aside from raw speed, the top players were doing something phenomenal: they were utilizing the fact that the games were double-blind to trick their opponents. With a game-mechanics version of vision rather than a simulated optical vision, and the units in the Blizzard RTS games are designed to counter each other in a circular way like rock-paper-scissors, the same mental bluffing and reading skills as are utilized by professional poker and chess became immensely valuable. In fact, many professional RTS players are world-class poker or chess players (with many after-hours poker games happening at RTS tournaments).</p> <p>In some ways, these skills of reading player intentions from small clues and bluffing the other players offset the sheer race for speed. For instance in a simple but common example if your enemy scouts your base, a high level player could fake-build an air unit until the scout leaves or is killed, then cancel it once the enemy can no longer see the base, thus baiting them into building tons of anti-air units, while all the while you actually built tanks. But this sort of shenanigans are only possible because of the way that both RTSs and subsequently MOBAs construct “vision” as a core game mechanic.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/3_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/3_5.jpg?itok=q-762LN7" width="700" height="429" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In a first person shooter, your character’s vision (also known as sight) and the vision you as a player have of your screen are the same and designed to seem naturalistic. Though often slightly caricatured, this means that a player sitting in the chair seeing what is on the screen better (such as catching a glint of a red uniform through a gap in a stone wall) effectively means the character in the game sees better (shooting said red-uniformed enemy through that tiny hole with a laser rifle). This naturalistic vision is not the way that MOBAs and RTS games work. What you the player sweating in a chair in the Los Angeles summer heat can optically see is overtly modified and limited to represent what the character on the map could ostensibly see. Most notably, this means parts of the screen are often rendered as blank or mostly darkened to represent areas that the character couldn’t see on the battlefield, called evocatively “The Fog of War.”</p> <p>Your character has a vision radius, as do your structures and minions, but these circles of sight are highly modified by the aforementioned bushes, architecture, and the general shape of terrain. Keeping tabs and predicting the movement of the opposing team even when they are not in vision is often one of the most frustrating aspects for new players and one of the defining characteristics of great players. Any player action has to be weighed against the abstract potential of any absent enemy: where they were, how fast they can move, teleports, their abilities to cross walls, bushes, etc. Short of having someone on your team have a character in vision, they could literally be standing right next to your character around a slight curve or in a bush. In fact, the colloquial term in <em>LoL</em> for this phenomenon is rated in “potential dudes in bush” such that if you can only see two enemy players, any given bush on the map potentially has three dudes in it waiting to clobber you. Calling “MIA” is one of the first things most new players learn to do, since the moment the opposing player in your lane isn’t visible, they could be headed anywhere to cause havoc.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/4_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/4_5.jpg?itok=OxN4lZtB" width="700" height="343" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Keeping track of these complex dark actions (or exploiting them yourself) is heavily influenced by two features, the mini map and wards. In all three MOBA games as well as <em>StarCraft</em> and <em>WarCraft</em>, there is a mini map which sketches out a small iconographic realtime representation of the general form of the map and everything your team currently has in vision and shares this information with your team (so everyone on a team has the same mini map). These maps are curiously interactive, and a player can actually click on them to move their character around in the same way as the “real” game map. Getting “mini-mapped” is the term used to describe clicking just slightly to far toward the bottom right of the regular game screen and accidentally clicking the upper left of the mini-map, thereby causing your character to walk in the exact opposite direction intended, usually toward certain doom. All three games now have an elaborate system that allows players to use key plus mouse combinations to signal missing enemies, potential objectives, retreat paths, and help requests both generally and on the mini map. <em>DotA2</em>’s map even allows players to temporarily draw on it, which as far as I can tell is mostly used for drawing penises while waiting to respawn after being mini mapped.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">DotA2’s map even allows players to temporarily draw on it, which is mostly used for drawing penises while waiting to respawn after being mini mapped.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In both <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em> the vision metagame is explicitly engaged with via the use of “wards” which are items that can be purchased with in-match resources (or as part of other items). Wards basically come in two flavors: ones that are invisible but grant normal vision around them, or the more expensive version that are visible but grant vision of invisible units as well, which most importantly allow a team to destroy their opponent’s wards. Placing and maintaining ward coverage as well as removing your opponent’s vision is a large part of competitive play, with numerous strategies and optimal warding points that have to be constantly contested. The latent large-scale combat strategy simulation aspect of these games is always present in the war for vision—trying to have knowledge of your enemy’s movements while masking your own—that visible territory is claimed territory. Vision is so critical, but simultaneously so banal, that in professional <em>LoL</em>, fans often cheer semi-ironically whenever a ward is destroyed during slow games. <em>LoL</em>’s focus on having jungle as a core position really ramps up the necessity of vision competition, since it is a whole position that exists out of vision most of the time and only shows up to leap out of the shadows when least expected. In fact, like last hitting, vision has become so central to <em>LoL</em>’s evolution of <em>DotA2</em> that the game has recently added a separate class of free items with their own inventory slot called trinkets which every character can choose that specifically either places a ward on a cooldown, grants vision of invisible units in a area on cooldown, or scouts a faraway location on command. Interestingly, vision and particularly wards have other odd uses and interactions since they are technically units. Some characters can use them as a place to jump to, and in <em>DotA2</em>, wards can block jungle camps, preventing them from spawning. Additionally, many characters have vision enacting or vision denying abilities which vastly complicate this perennial dance of the double-blind in RTS and moba games.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/5_5.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/5_5.jpg?itok=0ibVOuyJ" width="700" height="357" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Form feet and legs; form arms and body; and I’ll form the head!</strong></p> <p>Everything else aside that the two genres have in common, the fact that RTS games are played 1v1 and MOBAs are a team sport has grown to become the most critical difference. In professional games many <em>StarCraft</em> players will have specific selections of music on in the background, which are the same as they use to practice, while in MOBAs even with a professional team, the soundtrack every player hears is a chaotic barrage of 5 players yelling and trying to communicate via microphones. Ideologically, this change of focus from the self to the group radically affects the way the player identifies with the game. In an RTS, you are the top-level commander, or the hive-mind; you as a player are the abstract force that is sitting above the board controlling and binding together one army against the other mastermind’s army. Any mistakes are your own, and anything units that aren’t owned by the other player are yours to do with what you will. Your chance of winning is based on how in sync you are with yourself; how much you can both outplay and outthink your opponent.</p> <p>In a MOBA, you the player are embodied with an avatar in the game. Yes, the view is from above but the player is reaching into the game to manipulate the champion. You can only directly manipulate yourself (with some exceptions). The other four players have their own autonomous will, all while most of the creatures on the map are manipulated by AI and interact only through combat. Yes, speed, multitasking, and mind games are paramount, but now a new element is added: synchronization with other humans. In real terms, in <em>StarCraft</em> if your siege tanks move the wrong way and fire on the wrong enemy, it’s your fault while in <em>HotS</em>, unless you are playing the siege tank, you have no control over if your siege tank will even connect to the game, let alone attack a certain enemy!</p> <p>So much of the general tension in the overly-emotional tenor of the players in MOBA games seems to come from this general loss of control. Plays that can happen anywhere on the map are decided in fractions of a second and can spell disaster or success for the whole team. Even if players are both good, it is very easy to, with all of the guessing about vision and the frantic mechanical scramble, have differing reads of how to act in a scenario. For instance, in one recent game, I was playing as ADC (the high damage but fragile ranged attacker) and all four players in bottom lane stepped within range of fighting each other to contest a wave of minions that had gotten all tangled up. My support powered forward to attack their support since they saw an opening. At the same moment, I was already in process of retreating a few steps because of the other ADC pressuring me. I had seen the other ADC was taking heavy minion damage which would have left them horribly behind in lane. Honestly, either decision would have worked in our favor but in that fraction of a second we both chose the opposite reaction and he died and I was zoned out from the wave. Even on pro teams, finding players who can intuitively work together is a huge part of the support staff’s goals. At the biggest tournaments with the best teams and players, all of whom live and train 24 hours a day, coordination and synchronization mistakes regularly happen. The infinite-ceiling of speed in RTS games has been inverted to an infinite ceiling of multi-player coordination in MOBAs.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/6_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/6_3.jpg?itok=MOGhPqAe" width="700" height="315" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>This notion of player synergy—of all five players of a team acting like the five lions of Voltron—is ultimately what defines MOBAs from RTS games despite the bevy of legacy elements such as speed, multitasking, and vision as a mechanic. All three MOBAs are quite different though, and the elder <em>DotA2</em> can many times still feel a bit like being part of the RTS army of yore, with some heroes that barely have active abilities and others require lots of multitasking, some heroes even kill themselves to do damage and others require frantically micro-managing a dozen units all over the map. After all, the principles of having each part of an army do a specific job is still embedded from the RTS model. The MOBA middle child’s, <em>LoL</em>’s, major breakthrough was doubling down on <em>DotA</em>’s move toward a game of individual agency. They did this by bringing in a design team inspired by professional fighting games who reoriented the legacy RTS ideas to the highly controlled frame-specific animation interactions that defined the best games in the pro fighting game scene. They really reworked <em>LoL</em> to be about these “outplay” moments - where rather than long stretches of high APM, small lighting fast correct motions were prioritized and more importantly, rewarded, even during average moments of play.</p> <p><em>HotS</em>, with it’s radical removal of items and farming, moves even further away from the RTS legacy (and the label MOBA and is trying to focus on what game mechanics can push ever further toward multiplayer synchronization as the core skill required for a “hero brawler.” By giving players more embodied characters, and by creating a palpable narrative and pathos around team dynamics something quite interesting happened. Suddenly these esports games had vast stockpiles of inter-team stories to tell, and most importantly, unlike the inhuman speed of RTS players, they were stories or teamwork and comradery that any player could relate to, no matter the skill level. MOBAs were perfectly situated to become the nexus of the explosion in popularity of esports.</p> <p>Next time, we’ll take a look just how these games translate into the realm of professional sports.</p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> </ul> </div> Mon, 19 Oct 2015 14:11:42 +0000 Eron Rauch 632 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - PLAY: The Gory Farming of Glory https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory <span>Demystifying MOBAs - PLAY: The Gory Farming of Glory</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_3.jpg?itok=nkF9pAk7" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-10-08T10:43:20+02:00" title="Donnerstag, 8 Oktober 2015 - 10:43">Do. 8 Okt 2015 - 10:43</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs.</em></p> <p>In the previous editions of Demystifying Mobas I’ve broken down some of the basic elements such as the maps, characters, and history of the three major esports mobas, <em>DotA2</em> (Valve Corporation), <em>LoL</em> (Riot Games), and <em>HotS</em> (Blizzard/Activision). Now that we’ve shaken the hypothetical box, looked at the game board, and examined the pieces, let’s set these games in motion.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/1_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/1_3.jpg?itok=uE9Q8e6W" width="700" height="466" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In all three games, the timer starts the moment the players load in and everyone is given a couple minutes to purchase basic items and take up positions around the map before the baseline NPCs, called minions, start their incessant spawning. These unfortunate peons come in timed waves and mindlessly charge from the base down each lane and then fight the other side’s minions in a sad little battle when they meet. While they are hapless and fairly weak, there are plenty of complex rules and interactions that make minion movement, aggro (short for “aggression,” as their targeting algorithm is called), and manipulating the underlying logic a fundamental feature of high level play. One of the most critical differences between the <em>DotA2</em> cum <em>LoL</em> model and <em>HotS</em> is how these minions are utilized as resources in the game. In all three games being near a minion that dies gives a share of its experience to any player character that is nearby.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">Not only is gathering gold through last hitting important, it is also shockingly complex. </div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>But in both <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em>, something extremely important happens when a player is the one to strike the killing blow on a minion (“last hits”). To this fortunate and ruthless soul, a small amount of gold is given. Yet it is vital to understand that the gold is only given to the player who last hits the minion and that this gold, though seemingly small at first, adds up to be the fundamental mechanic for growing a character in power. Not only is gathering gold through last hitting important, it is also shockingly complex. To even skim the surface of last hitting, think about how at any second in any lane in the game competing players can be attacking each other, using multiple skills limited by health and mana, while either jungler can leap out of the bushes and gank at any point, and two waves of six minions each are in a cluster attacking each other. Do you use your mana to last hit, or to attack the opponent? Can you risk getting close enough to the far minions to kill them without getting low on heath and having to go back to the fountain? Can your opponent push you under your tower so the strong tower attacks hits the minions making it really difficult to predict when you should attack to last hit?</p> <p>This creates a huge amount of multitasking while in the laning phase, tracking a minimum of 14 characters’ (with three different kinds of minions) positions and health, watching 14 attacks going at once to try to estimate when you can leap in and take the last hit, as well as watching the rest of the map while communicating with your team. It is not an understatement to say that in most games the entire early portion of the matches in these two games revolves around this dance, which is termed “farming” (a gather grisly word for murdering henchmen for gold) especially considering both games are designed with the core ideal that players should be rewarded for being able to last hit near-perfectly and punished for failing.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/2_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/2_3.jpg?itok=w1apgtP1" width="700" height="357" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>L <em>oL</em> has made this farming integral to its attempt to construe balance as more firmly in the individual player’s (rather than the collective team’s) hands. To understand anything about pro play it is critical to understand how much of the resources minions make up and how drastically failing to kill minions can hamper a player. Killing a player is worth 300 gold (give or take) which equates to last hitting just around 15 minions. For reference, a perfect minion score at 25 minutes would be 305 CS (“creep score” - aka minions killed) and some pro players can actually hit above that level using some tricks! There is a small amount of ambient gold that every player gains just for being in a game, but just that 305 killed minions equates to 6814 gold gained. Given that big items cost around 3000 gold, a player who CSs 3 or 4 minions in every wave will still be a full item behind a perfect player at 25 minutes just from CS. This is critical because items are often multiplicative. So in real terms, if a player did merely passably by last hitting half of the possible minions, they would be able to buy a magic hat that gives [roughly] 25% more power on their spells at 25 minutes. If the opposing laner is a really great CSer, he will have that same +25% item, but will also [again roughly] have an item that gives them another 10% spell power and reduces the enemy’s magic resistance by 15%. Not only is there a second item for the better CSer, but note that given that CS is durational, the better last hitter would have their first item 30% faster, and their second item at the same time the unfortunate player who only last hit half of the minions got their first item.</p> <p>While this sound bad, it is actually much worse because the power disparity means that no matter what the lower CSer does the other player will have double the bonuses. Given the very tight balance of the games, this means that under no circumstance can they ever contest the stronger player in a fair one on one fight. In fact, it’s common in many games even at the pro level for it to become virtually impossible for a player that falls behind to even get close enough to last hit with a serious risk of dying. This cycle makes it even easier for the dominant player to perfectly CS and harder for the weaker player to get any CS at all. Getting progressively further ahead owing to maximizing a position in this exponential resource gathering system is called “snowballing.” While <em>DotA2</em>’s numbers are quite different, disparities can grow even quicker because if you’re faster than your opponent you can even kill your own minions (“denying”) to stop the other player from last hitting them. Even more punishing than <em>LoL</em>, in <em>DotA2</em> you actually lose some gold when you die, setting a losing player further behind. So while there is more emphasis placed on getting actionable items (like last week’s Blink Dagger) the snowballing effect of resources is still severe enough that pro games can be won or lost over seemingly small mistakes.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/3_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/3_4.jpg?itok=8ivBynv2" width="700" height="391" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>These continual advantages being given to the players who are ahead is one of the most common frustrations people have with <em>LoL</em> and <em>DotA2</em> (aside from the player base being abusive, which I’ll cover in a later section). MOBAs are a very curious beast of a sport in this way. While psychological factors can create one-sided matches in some sports, there are almost no sports where this sort of snowballing system is built in to the very deepest roots of rules. The sorts of snowballing resource systems common to MOBAs would be the equivalent of getting an extra player that is allowed on the field every time a team scores in football; being allowed a mulligan for free for every 3 hands of poker that a player won; or getting an extra down for every touchdown that was scored in American football. In hockey, you can end up being down or up a player, but only as a penalty for a team breaking the rules and only until the penalty timer runs out or the team scores. The only similar example in sports is car racing, where the leaders in the time trials are started at the front of the pack of cars, giving them a cleaner track. But this isn’t particularly relevant to MOBAs given that it’s physically dangerous to have slower cars in front of faster cars as well as the mitigation of being ahead that comes from using additional fuel while the cars in the back are able to conserve resources by drafting.</p> <p>The most pertinent example I could find in any game is the infamous way that the board game Monopoly tends to play out. Repurposed from an old socialist game called The Landlord’s Game which was designed to decry the evils of capitalism, even in the Parker Brother’s sanitized version, you can still ask any child why they hate Monopoly so much and they will, in so many words, basically point out that if one or two players are really lucky, they will get more money, so they can spend more money, so they get ever-further ahead and bankrupt the less lucky players without much those less fortunate players can do to come back. The first casualties then tend to get knocked out early and have to watch a movie for a couple hours while the other players slowly hoard more and more cash and try to grind each other down.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/4_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/4_4.jpg?itok=5_kVTJ5j" width="700" height="452" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>So much of the underlying dissonance between the perception of <em>LoL</em> and the actual way games tend to play out is rooted in the notion that killing your opponent seems to be but isn’t actually the primary objective, even though with a genre name like “multiplayer online battle area” it seems like it should be. Now knocking off your opposing laner is of course useful, but mostly because of how far behind the elaborate time of dying and walking back to lane can set them behind in both experience and gold. A new wave of minions spawn every 30 seconds, so if a player is dead for 30 seconds, then has to walk the minute or more to lane to start farming again, the lost farming time from two or three waves makes dying mathematically at least twice as severe as the the 300 kill gold makes it seem.</p> <p><em>HotS</em> makes its stance on de-prioritizing farming as a central element of the genre clear by eschewing the term MOBA altogether and calling the game a “team brawler.” As such <em>HotS</em> handles farming and laning entirely differently than <em>DotA2</em> or <em>LoL</em> in a quite deliberate fashion. This remains true to the stated goal of <em>HotS</em> to streamline the micro-oriented aspects of <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em> to make it more friendly to new and casual players. The minions still provide experience if a player is near the lane when they perish, but each team has an aggregate experience pool so every player on a given team will always be the same level. While there are a fixed number of minions per minute per lane in all three games, because farming is so critical in <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em>, the standard lane setups came about primarily to maximize resources per player. But in <em>HotS</em>, the goal is not to farm but to “soak” (which means to keep players gathering experience for the team) but since it doesn’t require anything more than having any player standing nearby at the moment the minions die, teams are free to wander around the map and put the “multiplayer online battle” back in MOBA.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/5_4.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/5_4.jpg?itok=tDuMnuvf" width="700" height="403" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Shopkeepers They Are Not</strong></p> <p>stacking.jpg ¬<br> (Well, this screenshot from Land of the Lost is kind of like <em>DotA2</em> stacking, yes?)</p> <p>Aside from the lane minions, all three games have additional fightable NPCs scattered around their maps. While these creatures do provide gold and experience, the most powerful of them also provide buffs and as such serve as important mini-objectives for teams to fight over in addition to the towers and nexuses. All of the games have these NPCs located in the jungle portion of the map (with a few exceptions for <em>HotS</em>) and they come in different flavors (called “camps”) which can be killed for resources and will respawn on fixed timers to be slaughtered again and again. In <em>DotA2</em> each kind of camp spawns in designated areas mirrored on both sides of the map, but the mixture of enemies in each camp is slightly randomized. The hardest camp is called the “ancients” (confusingly, since that is what the main objective is also called) which are strong monsters immune to magic and has a chance to spawn dragons, giant golems, or weird Land of the Lost triceratops-like dinosaurs.</p> <p>One of the main jobs of supports in <em>DotA2</em> is to “leash” these ancient camps which means to attack them once to get them to fight, then run away on a wild goose chase through the jungle for long enough that the game registers them as dead. Since they aren’t in their standard zone, this respawns a new set of ancients. After the new set spawns, that is the cue for the support to duck out of vision, causing the first set to go stand in the same camp as the new group of monsters. While this might not make much sense, and actually likely started as a bug, it was left in the game because the designers quite astutely recognized that it provides a very interesting mechanic since that means twice, three, or even four times the resources can be taken in the same amount of time. Since being able to dedicate as much time as possible to farming is critical for non-supports to get items, being able to send a support, who isn’t supposed to get gold anyway (and would get squashed by the powerful jungle monsters) to provide even more efficiency the gold earning potential of more core characters becomes an interesting and important part of pro play. This “stacking” isn’t without risks, since as each camps’ stacks get bigger they can become worth thousands of gold and become ever juicer targets for the other team to try to take.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/6_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/6_2.jpg?itok=vf215tA1" width="700" height="292" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>L <em>oL</em> has various jungle camps that come in standard mirrored positions with a fixed composition of monsters, with two of the harder-to-kill camps providing a buff (one to physical attackers, one to spell casters) to the person who last hits the leader NPC. Most importantly, the “blue buff” (in four years of playing I have never heard it called it by its real name, “Crest of Insight”) that comes with killing the Ancient Golem restores lots of mana, and at some point a smart jungler realized it was possible to almost kill it, but stop long enough for the mid laner, who is usually a mana hungry mage, to come by and take it. This provides a massive advantage so the other team is near-obligated to donate their blue buff to their mid laner too, and as such the securing and transfer of this buff has become a core element of the game. Camps can not be stacked in <em>LoL</em>, and the summoner ability that all junglers take, a spell called “Smite” (also the name of a <em>LoL</em> clone) does massive damage to these jungle minions and provides a different buff/ability depending on which kind of monster it is used on.</p> <p>By including Smite as a spell, by adding various masteries and runes that directly increase sustainability in killing jungle monsters, and then making sure the lanes had enough resources to exist on their own, <em>LoL</em> was able to formalize the jungler as a full time position in all games. In <em>DotA2</em> there are only a handful of full-time junglers, and while most of those characters farm in a manner analogous to (and probably inspired) <em>LoL</em> jungling, one of them is a very unique character named Shen which functions by controlling jungle monsters (aka “creeps”) in a somewhat similar way to the direction that was taken by the designers in <em>HotS</em>. In <em>HotS</em> the jungle monsters are treated completely differently. The basic jungle camps are actually termed “mercenaries,” on most maps come in different groupings, some with ranged attacks, some with melee attacks, and instead of dying once defeated join your team and walk to the nearest lane and start fighting for you. There are even abilities that let you convince them to fight without killing them (such as “Bribe”).</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/7_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/7_2.jpg?itok=PZjIFseT" width="700" height="403" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>All three games have various major NPC monsters which give a significant bonus to the team who successfully kills them, but also requires a large investment of resources or time to kill. Many big battles take place around these major NPCs, so much so that they are termed “objectives”. <em>DotA2</em> has a single major boss, called Roshan, which spawns at a fixed time and then will respawn after being killed on a randomized timer. This boss drops an “Aegis” which any player can pick up and will resurrect the player that holds it once. If it is killed enough times in a game, usually the sign of a stalled game, later kills of Roshan additionally drops a second advantageous item, a wheel of cheese which can be eaten to restore a hero’s health to full one time. <em>LoL</em> has two major boss NPCs, the dragon, which is a large monster that grants experience to everyone on the team that kills it, but more critically also a stacking series of buffs. A team that kills five dragons has such a massive buff that getting the fifth dragon kill provides a near certain lock on winning the game. This dragon buff win condition was not added to <em>LoL</em> until quite recently. Previously, dragons just granted some gold to everyone on the team, but as players got better and better at farming, this small amount of gold tended to become worthless later in a game and as such games would stall out over the lack of objectives that were worth fighting over late in the game. Now, the dragon becomes a more and more critical objective as the game goes on and teams can even try to rush a bunch of quick dragons which requires the other team to have to contest the fourth and fifth dragon, making for much more action packed games.</p> <p>Barron Nashor (“Roshan” backwards) is the other boss, who also provides global gold and experience as well as a short duration buff that significantly strengthens your nearby minions. Nashor’s buff has been heavily tuned through the history of <em>LoL</em> as well. In the many years of earlier iterations, it provided a buff to the team that succeeded in killing it that regenerated health and mana. Again, in favor of creating rules and mechanics that lead to dynamic games, this buff was switched so that it now directly buffs minions in lane near friendly players so that teams are encouraged by this temporary bonus to get in lane and make headway against the other team’s structures after taking Roshan. <em>HotS</em>, with its lack of in-match resources, has various flavors of bosses on each map that basically all have the same function as the rest of the <em>HotS</em> mercenary camps, only much much stronger, requiring almost the whole opposing team to group up to fight off its attack. Additionally, many of the maps can have novel but highly powerful NPCs of various sorts which perform specific functions or grant resources that help destroy the other team’s structures. In some cases, players can actually take control of them for a short while, becoming an NPC such as a statue come to life of a dragon knight or a Little Shop of Horrors style plant monster. Many of these encounters directly resemble the various raid bosses in World of Warcraft, with massive HP pools, circles of fire underfoot that need to be dodged, or area of effect stuns that melee characters have to time attacks around.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/8_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/8_2.jpg?itok=TMhv5GIX" width="700" height="411" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>As you can see, all three of these games are having an active conversation about how resource mechanics should determine the outcome of a games. <em>DotA2</em> being the first of these games has a diverse set of options. Some like losing gold on death is even more punishing than <em>LoL</em>, but others like stacking and item timings create novel ways around standard farming. <em>LoL</em>’s most fundamental change to the <em>DotA2</em> model was to create a large focus on individual responsibility by highly emphasizing the micro play of farming through last hitting minions. <em>HotS</em> chose the opposite model, trying to emphasis group play through freeing teams from being tied to lanes by removing last hitting and gold entirely.</p> <p>A big part of the interest in looking at all three of these games together is precisely to look for these sorts of moments of diverging design so that researchers can understand the historical roots of the mechanics, but also to showcase ways that designers can look at the various older elements in new ways to see new novel solutions for future games. Despite all of these differences all three games still have at their core a sense of balance that rewards victors with ever compounding advantages and losers with every spiraling gaps in resources.</p> <p><em>Next week we’ll examine this theme of intentional imbalance further by looking at MOBA’s roots in the real time strategy (RTS) genre.</em></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> </ul> </div> Thu, 08 Oct 2015 08:43:20 +0000 Eron Rauch 629 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield <span>Demystifying MOBAs - A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/1_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/1_2.jpg?itok=czW5_6_0" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-09-28T12:30:46+02:00" title="Montag, 28 September 2015 - 12:30">Mo. 28 Sep 2015 - 12:30</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs.</em></p> <p>In today’s instalment of “Demystifying MOBAs” we’re going to move on from the characters and take a look at the maps and landscape of Valve’s <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (<em>DotA2</em>), Riot’s <em>League of Legends</em> (<em>LoL</em>), and Blizzard’s <em>Heroes of the Storm</em> (<em>HotS</em>). One interesting way that many MOBAs resemble traditional sports fields (and chess) is that they have a single standard map for all competitive play. <em>LoL</em> has added a couple of variant game types which each have distinct maps, but these aren’t used in professional play so the focus here will be on the core map.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/2_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/2_2.jpg?itok=Pnt-knYL" width="700" height="729" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>DotA2</em>, the map is rather massive and is significantly asymmetrical (both functionally and aesthetically) between the two opposing sides with three lanes running top, middle, and bottom with jungle interspersed between them and a river bisecting the whole to delineate sides. One side is called Dire, and has a diabolical and burnt-out look, while the other is termed Radiant and has the look of an elvish forest. The entire <em>DotA2</em> map even has day and night cycles which affects how far characters can see at any given moment, with some characters like elves and demons having better night vision, or even additional powers once the sun sets. The sides are asymmetrical particularly when it comes to access to the various jungle camps and the routes that lead from the sides into the lanes. Radiant’s mid-lane is vastly more protected while Dire’s side has far more open space that enemy players can access. The layout of each side’s jungle is different and favors different characters and strategies.</p> <p>Significantly, Dire has vastly faster access to the biggest and most critical NPC monster, Roshan, which is one of the core objectives in the later parts of a match. One of the ways these differences affect high level play is that in pro matches, teams start by flipping a coin and the winner gets to pick if they want to choose their side or to pick the first character, so the best teams have worked out strategies for either outcome.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/3_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/3_3.jpg?itok=Wws7IOLr" width="700" height="729" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>LoL</em> has a very similar map to <em>DotA2</em>, which is to be expected given its history as a <em>DotA</em> clone, but while the <em>LoL</em> map is still fairly large it is more compact than <em>DotA2</em>’s sprawling map. Additionally, Riot has over the years made changes to the map in <em>LoL</em> to make it more symmetrical so there are not as many differences between the two sides. There are still a few differences, primarily in access to the two large NPC monsters located by the river, but for instance the jungle layouts are almost a mirror of each other. There is no day/night cycle in <em>LoL</em> so character vision remains consistent throughout the match. Rather than having one evil and one good side, the only visual differences between the two sides in <em>LoL</em> are the glow-colors in the depths of the jungle (which given the type and density of plants resembles more of a well-manicured park than a jungle).</p> <p>As with <em>DotA2</em>, teams get to select between picking sides or picking characters fist in professional matches. With both games there is a statistically significant difference in win-rates between the two sides, with <em>DotA2</em>’s difference mostly explained by Dire side’s easier access to Roshan. But in <em>LoL</em> the side advantage in pro matches can shift depending on the patch (basically depending on how valuable first pick is versus access to the big NPCs). Some top teams have figured out excellent strategies for playing the less advantageous side and can gain a large perk from being able to cede picking sides and get the first pick of characters or vice versa. That said, in amateur level play the side differences in <em>LoL</em> feel mostly negligible. As anyone who has tried to jump over a wall that they have jumped over for a hundred games and randomly failed has found out, it’s important to note Riot regularly makes changes to both the cosmetics of the map as well as the individual placement and size of terrain in their quest to make the two sides more equal.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/4_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/4_3.jpg?itok=fHmxds4D" width="700" height="449" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>HotS</em> breaks with the long MOBA tradition of utilizing a single map and instead has some similarity to <em>Super Smash Brothers</em> or <em>World Of Warcraft</em> Player Vs. Player Arena combat with a rotating map pool, currently made of nine different maps (called “battlegrounds”) with more promised to come. In <em>StarCraft 2</em>, Blizzard’s first successful esport, the Korean professional scene started rotating maps at the start of each different season as a way to keep strategies, metagames, and play styles fresh. One change that tends to disorient new players to <em>HotS</em> is that both <em>LoL</em> and <em>DotA2</em> both are oriented diagonally from lower left to upper right while <em>HotS</em> is played left to right. Every map in <em>HotS</em> has been highly symmetrical, with a few occasional changes in placement of NPCs to make sure that they don’t counter each other by being in the same lane. Most maps in <em>HotS</em> have three lanes, though not all of them. With the need to farm resources removed, each map additionally offers different objectives or mechanics that assist teams in winning, such as collecting resources from certain events that allows NPCs to fire artillery on enemy structures, or to work to raise a giant golem to fight for your team.</p> <p>Some maps are massive, others are tiny. Some are focused around a single objective, others require the team to split into groups. Some are open, other have twisty little passages. Some almost always have really short games, others almost always require very long games. In this way, each team has to come up with strategies specific to the map, rather than one master plan. Similarly, character selection becomes even more dynamic, since some characters excel on certain maps while being virtually useless on others. In basic casual play, this aspect is one of the most frustrating for new players, since the map is randomly determined after you pick your characters.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/5_3.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/5_3.jpg?itok=5_pGqkDR" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>If A Tree Falls On A Character And No One Hears…</strong></p> <p>One of the truly novel features of the <em>DotA2</em> map is that the trees that make up a large portion of the terrain are destructible with certain items and spells. Even the basic consumable healing item that most players buy for their character at the start of a match devours (destroys) a tree to heal the character. This leads to all manner of tricks, hidden pathways, and escapes that utilize this destructible terrain function to hide characters since the newly axed coves have the same rules for vision that make so much of the rest of the game blind. But environmentalists fear not, the trees always grow back quickly. The terrain in the <em>HotS</em> maps have cosmetic destruction that takes place when battles are fought nearby so if a spell is cast or a character is body-slammed nearby, pillars and walls will crack and crumble. But these changes are purely cosmetic, since the ruins still retain the identical functionality to block movement and vision. There is a separate sort of mini-structure which can be destroyed, but we’ll look at that later in this article during the discussion of towers since they are directly attached. <em>LoL</em>’s map has neither any changeable nor breakable terrain.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/6_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/6_1.jpg?itok=wzBDvVau" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Though lacking in destructible trees, one addition that both <em>LoL</em> and <em>HotS</em> use to make the map more interesting is that there are swaths of high grass (usually called “bushes” by players) that a character can stand in to hide. While in these bushes, the other team is totally unable to see the character unless they too are standing in the bushes. These are, of course, utilized quite extensively for surprise attacks, retreats, and fancy footwork plays since both top and bottom lanes have sections of bushes readily accessible in the sides of the lane. In both games, one amusing play that tends to happen even at the pro level is to have the whole team hide in a single shrub and all leap out at an unsuspecting passing enemy. In <em>LoL</em> they colloquially call this a “death bush” while in <em>HotS</em> they call it a “party bush.” Because of this, players will often call out a number of “Potential Dudes In Bush” to teammates who are wandering around. For instance, if no one on a team has vision of where four of the enemy team are, the team has to play as though any given bush could have four people in it, waiting to pounce.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/7_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/7_1.jpg?itok=PmqA5ehk" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>DotA2</em>’s map has no bushes, but offers one more mechanic, terrain level, that helps make it feel more like a real space than a flat chess board. In <em>HotS</em> and <em>LoL</em> the maps are exclusively two-dimensional maps (any visual elevation or recess is absolutely inaccessible or merely cosmetic) but <em>DotA2</em>’s map has what amounts to three or four levels of terrain in the game, with players on a level below having a chance for their attacks to randomly miss and lacking complete vision to the spaces above. Coupled with its radically more complex destructible tree-terrain and significantly larger size, <em>DotA2</em>’s map can often seem to be as much of an obstacle as the characters.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/8_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/8_0.jpg?itok=wsyX-pkm" width="700" height="264" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Lace Up Those Brown Bags And Hit The Trail, Er, Lane</strong></p> <p>Before I delve too much further into the idiosyncrasies of the maps, it is important to acknowledge that in all cases, traveling around the map is critical for any player. Each game has differing basic rules about character movement, as well as innumerable special cases and character powers which create a similar dynamic to how the different types of pieces in chess have different rules for movement. In <em>DotA2</em>, each character has a set basic movement speed, some faster and other slower, and then all characters can buy various kinds of boots in a match which can increase their speed (among other things). Additionally, each team can buy a courier which can be used by anyone on the team to shuttle items around to other characters and shops.</p> <p>The opposing team can kill the courier, putting its items in limbo for a number of minutes until the courier respawns. Especially in lower level games, this mechanic can be chaotic with multiple people randomly grabbing and resending the courier around, leading to it having the wrong items on it, since it has a limited carrying capacity, never arriving, or turning around just before it deposits the items. [Note: Most players in <em>DotA2</em> hold a grudge about the number of times they’ve been desperate to get a fantastic item delivered only to have another play waylay the courier to run their own errand.] While walking around is the typical mode of travel in MOBAs, as is fitting in a world of high fantasy, there are gobs of items and powers in <em>DotA2</em> which affect travel and team play drastically. For instance, for a tiny sum of in-match resources a character can acquire a consumable teleport scroll (assuming the courier isn’t doing laps in the forest) which can be used to move to any friendly building for a last second defense or to reinforce a big fight.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/stobX0LYphk?start=80" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stobX0LYphk" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stobX0LYphk</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>At 1:20, you can see Looper, aka “God of Teleports” come crashing into an otherwise lost team fight.</em></p> <p>In <em>LoL</em> movement is similar, with each character having a unique base move speed, some slow, some speedy, which can be changed by buying one of the assortment of available boots. But <em>LoL</em> adds a convenient feature that enables any character to return to the place they started the game, called the “fountain.” This spell, called Recall, requires the character to do nothing but cast it for eight seconds and any damage or crowd-control (stuns, roots, or knock-backs) taken cancels the recall. Many, many ridiculous deaths have occurred from casting this spell in poorly chosen places. Korean pro players are quite notorious for getting cocky and Recalling in the middle of an area swarming with enemies and ending up as a humiliating casualty.</p> <p>Characters in <em>LoL</em> can, as part of the pre-game tuning process I’ve already discussed, choose one of their options to be a teleport spell which lets them go to any friendly unit (building, object, ward, or character) once every four minutes. I bring this up because in the current version of <em>LoL</em> (which is critically the same version that the World Championship will be played on) games are often made or broken on a team’s teleport coordination. Imagine the potency of having your jungler show up to make it a 3v2 in bottom lane when suddenly, via Teleport, the enemy top laner evens out the fight by spamming spells in your midst.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/9_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/9_0.jpg?itok=37k31aEw" width="700" height="420" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>HotS</em> has a much simplified version of these systems. All characters travel at the same speed on foot (with one exception) and most have a mount they can get on and off at will (with a short 4 second cooldown) which increases their speed but which instantly goes away if hit by any attack. A couple characters transform into their mounts, and the shapeshifter Rengar is even allowed to switch in combat to his wolf form. Like <em>LoL</em>, all characters can recall to their fountain at any point.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/10_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/10_0.jpg?itok=ejEYRJE2" width="700" height="333" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Fancy Footlesswork</strong></p> <p>Across all three games, characters have a variety of abilities to speed themselves up, speed up other characters, or even teleport in various ways, though <em>LoL</em> has marginally less characters with built-in long distance teleports than <em>DotA2</em> or <em>HotS</em>. But one telling feature of the MOBA genre is that all three major games include a way for every character to teleport short distances instantly. This short ranged, instant movement can be used for innumerable purposes and the way that all three games give players this genre-defining power is very different, and is telling of their overall design philosophies. <em>LoL</em> technically has two slots for tuning your character out of the match with “Summoner Spells” (there’s that legacy term popping up again) yet one of them is almost always the “Flash” spell, which instantly jumps you a short distance on a three minute cooldown (a cooldown is merely the term for the length of time when a spell unavailable until it is useable again). This spell so vital to the game balance that it is basically a core mechanic for how everything interacts. 99% of players take it every match and the characters all have to be designed with Flash’s nearly infinite uses in mind. For instance when designing a hypothetical character, even if Riot provides the champion with no gap-closing ability but their own two stubby legs, but gives them an awesome area-of-effect (AOE) stun at short range, the designers have to take into account that with Flash selected, our hypothetical character can hide behind a wall, Flash over the wall and stun a whole group of unsuspecting opponents every three minutes no matter how slow they are the rest of the time.</p> <p>Flash interacts equally deeply with defensive aspects, since it allows immobile champions to instantly escape an otherwise inevitable death. In fact, if Flash were removed tomorrow, vast swaths of characters would be abandoned because their very viability is hinged on having that Flash either to engage or escape. At the pro level, knowing whether enemy Flashes are available or on cooldown is one of the core elements of choosing opportune times to fight.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/3ElXGllTpp0" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ElXGllTpp0" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ElXGllTpp0</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>With <em>DotA2</em>, there isn’t any equivalent ability selection like <em>LoL</em>’s Summoner Spells, but you can trade in-match resources for a Blink Dagger, which you can activate every 20 seconds to instantly warp to a spot near you. The reach is much further than Flash but because a Blink Dagger requires quite a bit of resources to get, takes up one of the only six inventory slots, and provides no additional combat benefits usually only characters who can utilize it directly build one. In <em>LoL</em> you can see the other side’s summoner spells at the beginning of a match, but in <em>DotA2</em> items are hidden until the other team is physically close enough to click on the opposing character. Since Blink Dagger is an item, this can lead to very dramatic and tactical reveals where a dangerous character suddenly warps into the middle of a seemingly safe team and casts a massive spell that decimates the unsuspecting team.</p> <p>Characters with spells that are centered around the character but do massive AOE damage and stuns, like Tidehunter’s “Ravage” which throws all enemies up in the air cancelling whatever they were doing, or Earthshaker’s “Echo Slam” which causes a shockwave all around himself that stuns and then does compounding additional damage for every enemy player it hits, basically rely on the Blink Dagger to be relevant. This highlights how, though they seem like separate systems, the characters and the items are actually two sides of the same coin, and are intimately interrelated.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/11_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/11_0.jpg?itok=ei014fgz" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>HotS</em> with its complete lack of out of game tuning and absence of items has a slightly different notion of how these instant cast teleports impact the game, though their use is very much still based on the understanding of how massively impactful such suspensions of typical movement rules can affect the game. Specifically Blizzard doesn’t provide an instant short ranged teleport on most characters until you hit the in-match level cap of 20.</p> <p>At that point, the player is presented with four options, some that provide more damage, others that modify a major ability significantly, and one of which is “Bolt of the Storm”, which functions very similar to Flash but on a shorter 70 second cooldown. In this way, Bolt, with all of the ways these sorts of spells radically affect MOBA tactics, only comes into effect at the end of very long games as a way to create exponentially more options for one team or the other to make hugely impactful plays.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/12.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/12.jpg?itok=CWAwcCAr" width="700" height="264" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Objective Is In Site</strong></p> <p>While many games, both analog and video, have two teams playing on a field with opposed goals dabbling with the metaphor of war, in the case of MOBAs, the goal is much more warlike, with the end goal being to physically destroy the opposing side’s architectural structures and ransack their inner sanctum. Thinking about narrative implications, it is curious that in none of the three games under consideration does this core actually provide any sort of in-game benefit aside from being the location where the weakest NPCs regularly spawn from. It is nearly a structural Mcguffin. This structure is termed the “Ancient” in <em>DotA2</em>, a “Nexus” in <em>LoL</em>, and a “Core” in <em>HotS</em>. All explode when defeated. Oddly, the statue that is the core in <em>HotS</em> also shoots out assorted gold and riches, like a thousand <em>Diablo</em> bosses popping at once.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/13.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/13.jpg?itok=9xRsvYaN" width="700" height="608" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Despite their rather small footprint, there are additional structures on the field that delineate the lines and zones of battle. The primary form of structures on the map are called towers in both <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em>. They are a solitary structure jutting out of the landscape that automatically attacks enemy characters (both players and NPC) that come within its range, effectively creating a safe zone for friendly characters. There are three towers in each of the three lane in both games and the towers in front (called “outer”) that must be destroyed before the towers nearer the home base are vulnerable (called “inner”).</p> <p><em>HotS</em>, as befitting its interest in creating interesting spaces for team fighting with its maps, has a more architecturally complex system for most of its maps in which instead of a tower, each safe zone is a small encampment with a variety of destructible towers, walls, a gate, and other buildings, which protects a main “keep” and a healing fountain which can help regenerate hurt allies. The destructible walls are an interesting element to <em>HotS</em> because they can cut off vision or block manoeuvres around the tower zones, yet do not respawn after being destroyed. The gate automatically falls when the two font towers on either side of it fall.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/14_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/14_0.jpg?itok=Z3gTrKfF" width="700" height="465" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>LoL</em>, the attacks from the tower actually do progressively more damage to a character the more hits a target takes within a short period making towers quite deadly early in the game but slowly becoming less effective since beefier characters get items like armor that inevitably make the towers do less damage. In <em>DotA2</em>, towers are quite comparably weak per hit, but they have a longer range and attack much faster, which makes it harder to dodge the damage but easier to predict how much damage you might take if you are targeted. By the end of a game, tower attacks are barely dangerous at all. The tower attacks in <em>HotS</em> are actually quite mild and easily ignorable in the short term after a few minutes of levelling up.</p> <p>Most interestingly <em>HotS</em> has added a new feature, which is that towers, forts, and keeps have limited ammo which means they can run out of attacks become merely giant brick-and-mortar punching bags so even though last hitting minions is pointless, there is a very real consequence of being undefended by letting the other team push wave after wave of minions against your towers soaking up tower hits. Both <em>DotA2</em> and <em>HotS</em> have characters with abilities to heal towers, but in <em>LoL</em> there is no way to gain HP back on towers though a handful of abilities can shield towers briefly. In all three games, killing a tower gives everyone on a team, not just the player who killed it, experience points and in <em>LoL</em> and <em>DotA2</em>, a significant amount of gold.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/gMf4NFK8Tig" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMf4NFK8Tig" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMf4NFK8Tig</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>A piece of animation from Carbots Studio that nicely shows the use of towers and healing wells during the laning phase in HotS.</em></p> <p>Riot has been tinkering with towers in <em>LoL</em> for some time to give them buffs in the early parts of the game, including more armor and more damage. Inner towers now even give shields to nearby friendly players. It’s a bit obscure how these changes came about, but critical to understand since the towers define such a large portion of the play for the early portions of the game through being so dangerous to low level opposing players. Basically if the towers do too much damage there is no incentive to risk any aggression so the early game becomes boring and static, while if there isn’t enough damage and defensive stats the friendly player relying on its power is hapless against an enemy onslaught. These are both very real issues that <em>LoL</em> has had to deal with over the years.</p> <p>Particularly with the rise of the professional play, incredibly effective but somewhat bland strategies were discovered where teams could group and tear down a couple towers in the earliest minutes so teams just stopped sending players to fight and both teams would race each other to tear down towers. Similarly, after that it became common for teams to send enough people to disregard the safe zone around the tower and have a nearly 100% chance to kill a player in the first three levels (which was the exact timeframe that towers were supposed to be protecting low level players) so then Riot super-buffed the towers and the junglers had no chance of success to gank (which is parlance for unexpected showing up and killing a laner) and just stayed in the jungle farming for fifteen minutes. So while towers have a small footprint in terms of space compared to the rest of the map, they actually define the movements that are available until the latest portions of the game.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/15.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/15.jpg?itok=tfWhRjs9" width="700" height="328" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>The base, a space that starts at the final tower and extends to the nexus/core/ancient is separated out from the rest of the map by a series of permanent walls &amp; fortifications and houses a series of other structures much like a medieval castle. In <em>DotA2</em>, the base features a bunch of cosmetic buildings and then the ranged and melee “racks,” short for barracks. Destroying these will permanently cause the team who successfully killed the barracks to spawn stronger minions in that lane thus giving them an advantage since their reinforced minions waves will constantly push the line of battle forward. <em>HotS</em> has a “keep” as its second set of structures in each lane which is similar in arrangement to the outer areas but if destroyed causes long-range catapults to be permanently spawned by the team who destroyed the keep. <em>LoL</em> is very similar, but has no cosmetic buildings and only one “inhibitor” (a giant gem structure) in each lane. Once an inhibitor is killed the team who successfully destroyed an enemy inhibitor gets an extra minion, called a super-minion, which is as its name implies, stronger than usual, which moves down the lane. Interestingly, the inhibitor respawns after a short time though not the tower that protects it. In all cases, killing one of these inner structures creates massive pressure in that lane since the extra strong NPCs that spawn force the team who lost it to be constantly and actively working to defend that lane against the increased NPC onslaught.</p> <p>In all three games, getting an inner structure killed is usually the beginning of the end for a team. In <em>DotA2</em>, losing the first racks corresponds to a nearly 90% game loss rate in pro tournaments, and in fact is usually only attempted late in a game by a team who has accumulated an overwhelming advantage. Much like in professional chess, <em>DotA2</em> games are rarely played to checkmate (the destruction of the Ancient), but end with the team who lost one or two racks accepting their nearly impossible position and surrendering. It is considered incredibly disrespectful for a pro team to refuse to surrender a clearly lost game (in <em>StarCraft</em> players have even been suspended for this sort of behavior). In <em>LoL</em>, the numbers aren’t quite so bleak, since the inhibitor respawns, and in fact there is a strange tendency for teams who take an inhibitor too early to lose because the waves of minions are mostly near the well defended sections of the enemy base, so the team with the inhibitor down is actually at an advantage to safely farm minions.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/16.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/16.jpg?itok=iqxhA4N4" width="700" height="718" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Shop Therapy</strong></p> <p>To conclude our tour of these digital battlefields, at the far back end of the base in all three games is a safe zone (of sorts) called a Fountain which will automatically heal friendly characters over a short time and in <em>LoL</em> and <em>DotA2</em> also unleash very strong attacks on opposing players which almost instantly kill them. The “almost” portion is critical because it shows just how ruthless these two games can be to new players, since even the most protected space on the map includes the possibly of an opposing player making a nearly suicidal dive and killing you. Particularly, this is used as a way to flaunt a victory at the very end of a match, butchering the opposing team on their own Fountain. The Fountain also is where you start the game and where characters respawn after dying.</p> <p><em>HotS</em> has made this zone completely inaccessible to the other team. In both <em>DotA2</em> and <em>LoL</em> this safe zone is also a shop that allows you to shop for items with the gold you earn in the match by killing minions and characters. Between respawning, healing, and buying items, throughout any game any player will be spending a significant amount of time using it as a hub for their forays out into the wilds of the map.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/17.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/17.jpg?itok=tkeMO3wm" width="700" height="465" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>DotA2</em> has a pair of additional shops on each side of the map. One is a small side shop which has a limited selection of rudimentary items conveniently located near the battlefront, which is useful because unlike <em>HotS</em> and <em>LoL</em>, there is no spell to get you freely back to base. Additionally, <em>DotA2</em> has a “secret” shop sequestered in each side of the jungle, which sells a small selection of exotic and expensive components that the main shop doesn’t have but which are required ingredients to assemble the most potent items in the game. One of the fascinating decisions in <em>DotA2</em> was to allow players to buy from any shop they can physically access, not just their own team’s shops, so invading teams often make a quick purchase as they retreat out of the other side’s jungle. Though I don’t exactly know what to make of it, it seems worth noting that in both of these games, the safest, best defended place on the map, which is also where you return from the dead and where you heal your battle wounds, also is a store. Maybe that just shows good business sense from the vendors. In <em>HotS</em> there are no items and the only other benefit you get from the Fountain is that you can mount instantly, but while seemingly small, this is yet another place where Blizzard tries to remove some of the typical MOBA barriers, like <em>DotA2</em>’s extended walk to the outer tower which can take over a minute each way, which is almost 3% of the length of a match.</p> <p>In this chapter hopefully I have been able to show how the various aspects of the games that seem unrelated (characters, maps, items, and structures) are actually critically related to each other in one organic system. If a change is made to any element, no matter how seemingly insignificant, there can be drastic effects on the perception and value of other elements in the system especially at the highest levels of play where fractions of a percent can be game-changing, finding, understanding, and utilizing information can define victory. In a basic way, things like the tower buffs in <em>LoL</em> or character movement ability cooldowns in <em>DotA2</em> are why so much effort is spent scrutinizing patches from every angle.</p> <p><em>Next week, we’ll look at how the inhabitants of these eternal battlefields are a form of resources and how the different ways each game distributes these resources are based on differing views of “balance.” Additionally, we will examine these three games’ use of “vision” as a game mechanic, rather than a simulation of optical vision, and how this mechanic is one of the most defining elements of the MOBA genre.</em></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> </ul> </div> Mon, 28 Sep 2015 10:30:46 +0000 Eron Rauch 625 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs - The Pantheon in Action https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action <span>Demystifying MOBAs - The Pantheon in Action</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_2.jpg?itok=VPiL4m52" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-09-15T13:17:07+02:00" title="Dienstag, 15 September 2015 - 13:17">Di. 15 Sep 2015 - 13:17</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay <a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas">"Demystifying MOBAs"</a> takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs. <a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part one</a>, <a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">part two</a></em></p> <p><strong>Wait, What’s A Mid-Fielder Again?</strong></p> <p>Moving on from last week’s examination of representation and art styles in mobas, each of the three games we’ve been looking at in the series also has a rather different idea about your relationship to your character and what it should be doing in the game. It’s important to note that in all three games, each of the five players that make up a given team will fill different roles, which are similar to positions in other sports like baseball or football. <em>DotA2</em> has by far the most complexity and fluidity in character positions, but as is typical for all three games, each player will eventually come to specialize in a particular role or position.</p> <p>There are unofficial subsets of the characters that are considered “correct” in each role, though there is nothing aside from poor strategy to prevent “wrong” characters to be used in any given position. At the most basic level, each character in all three games has a combination of six or more abilities. These abilities determine the characters’ usage in any given team. For instance, one character could be very fragile but have abilities that rain down damage afar, while another character might be able to only attack up close, but can go invisible to close that gap to the fragile character. Similar to a football match, games are played out strategically based on the strengths and weaknesses of each team.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/moba3b_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/moba3b_0.jpg?itok=ME0YWwgk" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>For <em>DotA2</em>’s positions, you typically have two “cores” split between mid-lane and top-lane, two “supports” and then a more flexible position that called a “safe-lane.” There is a large degree of flexibility in team composition even at the pro level. Sometimes these positions are also called by number, one through five, which designates how much of the in-match resources the team is trying to gather for the player. So if you’re position one, your team is actively trying to find you the most gold and items, while if you are position five, you are deliberately trying to avoid taking resources away from the rest of your team.</p> <p>This is not hard-coded into the game, and can change within any given match. If for instance, the mid-lane core, typically position one or two, gets totally shut down, but the another position such as the support somehow got way ahead the team can make the call to now treat them as position one, giving them more money and protection. In <em>DotA2</em> tournaments, it’s typical to see almost 90 % of the characters get played at some point across all the games, and players are expected to know all the main characters in their position, which is emphasized by having every champion available to all players. Occasionally there are sneaky player-champion-position change-ups that are used to confound the opposing team. That is, sometimes teams will put players on non-standard or weird characters for their position simply because the other team won’t know how to play against it.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/moba3a.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/moba3a.jpg?itok=6OryqfAk" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>LoL</em>, you have characters in positions named after the physical location on the map they occupy: top-laner, mid-laner, jungler, and then what is called the “duo lane” at the bottom, made up of support and the marksman (though almost no one calls it that - instead informally terming it “AD Carry,” referring to the fact that this position is the ranged character who does physical, or “Attack Damage”). Occasionally at the highest level of professional play, the top and bottom lane will switch position for tactical reasons, but everything else is pretty locked in place. Note that <em>LoL</em> is the only game out of the three with jungler as a fixed position. The jungler is a position that roams the entire map to gather resources and help teammates while moving through the areas between lanes; <em>DotA2</em> allows that style as a team choice with a certain subset of characters, while <em>HotS</em> has no equivalent (since resource allocation is universal, not individual).</p> <p><em>LoL</em> is very different than <em>DotA2</em> in that players, even top-tier pros, have what are termed “champion pools”, which are a small subset of characters from their role, usually between three and six, that they play well enough to field at the highest level. To emphasis the difference to <em>DotA2</em>, one of the best marksmen of the first few years of competitive <em>LoL</em>, known as Genja, only played one character (Ashe) in all of his many hundreds of games prior to reaching the upper echelon of the rankings! Much like fighting games, this means that even at the lowest skill levels of <em>LoL</em> most players will have what are dubbed “mains,” which are the small handful of characters they are skilled at. In tournament terms, that means you’ll see a much smaller percentage of the champions played across the games and a large part of the meta-game is tripping up the other team by preventing them from playing their mains.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/moba3g.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/moba3g.jpg?itok=uzfNqHkK" width="700" height="280" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">Everyone fights to play the spectacular positions - often based on what was making superstar plays in esports broadcasts.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>HotS</em>, there isn’t nearly as developed a metagame as in the other two titles yet. But the strategy for picking characters and assembling a team is mostly focused around the players each having a specific role to enact. The game, very much like a basketball team, is mostly about moving around the map as a unit. One player specializes in the burly tank character (warrior), two specialize in fragile damage dealers (assassin), one specializes in support (known as… support), and then the fifth member is a generalist “flex” player, who can play most of the champions in the game to round out whatever team setup is needed. Much like <em>DotA2</em>, <em>HotS</em> players are usually required to play every character in their role, often with a few overlapping characters from other roles, and most tournaments see most characters played, though there are always an upper tier of priority or strong characters that define the game at any given moment. In all three games, one of the most common conversations (arguments) before a pick-up game is who will take which position. At any given moment everyone fights to play the spectacular positions, often based on what was making superstar plays in esports broadcasts. Traditionally, these superstar roles have been the mid-lane and carry positions, but one of the defining changes that <em>LoL</em> enacted (which carried over to <em>HotS</em>) is to make support positions more equitable and to actively promote supports as impacting play in major ways.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Glorious Limitations and Limitations To Glory</strong></p> <p>Having picked a character and role (or been forced into one by a bunch of rude strangers), in each game a new player will very quickly start to notice there are wildly differing notions for how each character has the power to affect a given match. <em>DotA2</em> has a massive spectrum of character strength and circumstances in which a given character is strong. Though that sounds rather abstract, it is practically felt everywhere in that some characters can easily win the game by themselves if they can collect resources for the first thirty minute of the game; while some characters basically don’t become any more useful after 20 minutes no matter how many resources they get; some characters dominate the game if they get the resources they need, but are wet noodles if starved out; others don’t need any resources and don’t even grow much if they do have resources; some characters provide general support; others can almost instantly kill another character but add nothing else to the team. Some characters have just two active abilities, while others have a dozen, with all the pratfalls and mistakes that come along with that complexity.</p> <p>In fact, in <em>DotA2</em> it’s common for supports to finish even a winning game with basic boots and one small item that buffs the team while the core positions might have a small army’s worth of magic swords and glowing armor by the end. Radical diversity of options is the motto of <em>DotA2</em> and putting together a selection of five characters that have interesting interactions and knowing where and when they are strong is a huge part of professional play. If, for instance, you see the other team forming around characters that start off weak but slowly become unstoppable, you can build a team that starts off insanely strong but doesn’t get much better and completely run them over at the beginning of the game.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-video paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-video field--type-video-embed-field field--label-hidden"> <div class="embed-consent" data-provider="youtube" data-src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/ZPCfoCVCx3U" style="aspect-ratio:16/9"> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPCfoCVCx3U" rel="noopener">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPCfoCVCx3U</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>(Video: An example of counterplay in LoL)</em></p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>LoL</em> there is an emphasis on very precise 1v1 solo play in lanes early, and then transitioning into coordinated teamwork later in the match. Some characters are stronger earlier and fall off later, while some grow more in strength, but those extremes are much closer together than in <em>DotA2</em>. It is possible for a character in <em>LoL</em> to get out of hand, but that is because they were able to earn their way to that position though garnering many small advantages early, not because of some automatic rock-paper-scissors character picking. There is some difference in the kinetic nature of champions in different roles, particularly with supports not having quite the same level impact on the game as the other positions (top ranked players are mostly mid and jungle). But while Riot started with <em>LoL</em> being quite similar to <em>DotA2</em>, with Riot’s interest in fighting game ideals of “counterplay” (which will be discussed in greater detail later) they have been explicitly giving supports more equal resources and playmaking opportunities and also been actively down-tuning characters that run away with games.</p> <p>In <em>HotS</em>, characters interact like Voltron - all five combine to fight as one, or in less metaphorical terms, teamwork provides almost all the playmaking potential. The game is tuned so that dying in a 1v1 is pretty hard to do unless a player makes a large mistake. The gathering of resources also doesn’t require attacking the minions, merely being near them, which means that pro play revolves around making smart, fast, decisions to call for help, assessing danger, or going to help teammates all over the map. Almost all the champions contribute evenly to a given game, though there is still a split between what precisely damage dealers, tanks and support try to do. Since all resources are shared (such as experience points) all characters on a team are at the same power level, any player choice, successful or not, is actively balanced by the overall performance of the team.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/moba3c.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/moba3c.jpg?itok=cSatnfOw" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>I was told there wouldn’t be math</strong></p> <p>One of most subtle but weirdest differences is the way each game uses numbers. All three utilize a typical Role Playing Game style stat system with hit points and mana that are based on the Japanese <em>Final Fantasy</em> mode with characters that have many thousands of HP. But for all other numbers, the three games are very different: <em>DotA2</em> uses really small numbers, <em>LoL</em> has inflated numbers, and <em>HotS</em> mostly hides statistical numbers. For instance, a character in <em>DotA2</em> that has 10 base armor is pretty amazing, while in <em>LoL</em> all characters have somewhat arbitrary numbers, so that an armor of 110 is about the same as that 10 <em>DotA2</em> armor. Interestingly, in the newest game, <em>HotS</em>, there aren’t any easily user-visible stats like armor, and Blizzard has chosen a streamlined but more opaque way of dealing with bonuses by merely having abilities say they “reduce” or “increase” certain kinds of damage, usually by a percentage. This means that at the most superficial level you can’t really talk about armor in <em>HotS</em> (novel for a fantasy RPG game!).</p> <p>These numerical choices really showcase the differing philosophies of the games. <em>DotA2</em>, with its massive free champion pool and wildly dramatic game and team differences, uses smaller numbers to facilitate on-the-fly conscious decisions about what you want to do with items and abilities within each match. It’s easy to do 10-5 or 5+5 even while you’re sneaking around a massive forest. <em>LoL</em>’s approach is based on the fact that most players only play a few heroes, and that relative to <em>DotA2</em>, they have to make less subtle choices about items, and that much of the subtle math is handled during an out-of-match system called runes and masteries. Like car racing setups, these are small but highly complex multi-tiered systems of tuning that includes things to pre-shape and slightly customize the stats of those small number of characters you’ll be playing to find small advantages. These setups are then additionally modified by items in the match which are picked less for their actual numbers than because they are tailored toward a scenario or another. Most characters have an ideal “build” and any deviation is then only going to probably be swapping one item for another.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/moba3d.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/moba3d.jpg?itok=XOrHxflj" width="700" height="187" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>In <em>HotS</em>, Blizzard is very openly trying to simplify these traditionally arcane systems that require great deals of outside research and has jettisoned items, runes, and masteries altogether and instead designed an simple in-match system where you pick your character’s bonus abilities as you go from a small handful of options such as, “on reaching level 5 chose one: buff melee attacks; or receive an aura that heals friends.” Choosing a unique path for each match as you level up means you can have some flexibility to tune the character, but with no out-of-match tuning nor in-match items to make modifiers on the champion, there is no reason to worry about the small numbers. To make up for this, the game is unique in that at it offers not one, but two options for the characters’ ultimate ability which often has radically different and drastic effects. These decisions make for a vastly more accessible game that tries to limit knowledge-based boundaries for casual players.</p> <p><strong>In summary</strong></p> <p>From the representational choices and history of the artwork, to the way they envision the roles each player-character combination should take in their team, to the very subtle ways they deal with translating strengths and weakness in to math, each node in the vast field of MOBA design decisions provides a small window to peer at the way these three games work differently from each other. Not only that, but the way these design decisions interact with economic realities of these mammoth games and indicate certain world views for their respective esports audiences shouldn’t be underestimated even if they exist primarily in a nearly subconsciously accepted fashion for the average player. Above all, characters are the foundational element of all three games and the notion of a player taking real-time control of a single unit in a Real Time Strategy game while also interacting with numerous other players in a team setting is one of the most novel and dynamic ideas to come from the rise in MOBAs.</p> <p>In next week’s installment, we’ll take a closer look at the battlefield in which these character act.</p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> </ul> </div> Tue, 15 Sep 2015 11:17:07 +0000 Eron Rauch 622 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon <span>Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_0.jpg?itok=TiAjxS2e" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-09-07T20:41:30+02:00" title="Montag, 7 September 2015 - 20:41">Mo. 7 Sep 2015 - 20:41</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay "Demystifying MOBAs" takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs. Part one is <a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">here</a></em></p> <p>While MOBAs seem quite basic, their design decisions are often focused on the interaction of small details and procedures. What can on the surface seem familiar and simple from other video games can quickly blossom into a panoply of complications in MOBAs. As such, there are innumerable places to start our comparative re-examination of <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (aka <em>DotA2</em>, published by Valve Coportation), <em>League of Legends</em> (aka <em>LoL</em>, published by Riot Games), and <em>Heroes of the Storm</em> (aka <em>HotS</em>, published by Blizzard Entertainment), but I’m going to open by examining and exploring one of the first things that any player will do after starting one of these games: picking a character to play.</p> <p>In <em>DotA2</em> and <em>HotS</em> the characters a player picks from are simply named “heroes” since they are the virtual representation of you, the player, while in <em>LoL</em> your character is called your “champion.” This is because in the <em>LoL</em> world mythology, you, the player, are actually playing as a separate but never shown in-game personality called a “summoner” who is a wizard and political figure who through some manner of unexplained virtual-reality-mind-control elects and takes control of another character in the world for each combat. This interposed (and rather meta) relationship of the player and character was written out of the backstory in late 2014, but Riot has kept the term champion and somewhat confusingly now uses the term summoner interchangeably with “player” during their esports broadcasts. It is still possible to see a number of other legacy uses of the term such as the main map of <em>LoL</em> being called “Summoner’s Rift” e.g. the place where summoners disagree and work out their political differences and personal grudges.</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/01_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/01_2.jpg?itok=KN6wMxk2" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>The relationship of characters to narrative is also fundamentally vastly different between the games, and tends to indicate many larger design intentions. In <em>DotA2</em>, the characters names are abstracted into archetypal names in a manner similar to chess pieces or tarot cards, such as “the Bishop” or “the Fool”. In <em>DotA2</em>, champions are mostly named generically such as “Dragon Knight,” a knight who can turn into a dragon, or “Invoker,” a mage who casts a wide variety of spells. Given its history as a fan-made modification of another game, it is important to note that it also has few non-sequitur name references to anime such as “Lina the Slayer”. In this way, <em>DotA2</em> constantly re-emphasizes its focus on systems, strategy, and rational analysis, on its status as a game, over any form overt narrative passion.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/02_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/02_1.jpg?itok=e3IxJDrt" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>When it comes to <em>LoL</em> all of the characters exist as specific properly-named characters such as Jarvan IV and Irealia that exist in a coherent world that is in the midst of a war between two empires similar to Boromir and Saruman in <em>Lord of the Rings</em>. But the specific narrative material is often such offhanded genre filler that even the casters (paid by Riot) will openly mock its insipidness during official event broadcasts. In a strange predictive twist of fate, the internet slang term for this sort of nonsense backstory has from a time long before <em>LoL</em> been nicknamed “lolore.” But giving all of the characters specific names, stories, and personalities takes a great deal of time (and hence money), so why would Riot, who made their game as a clone of <em>DotA2</em>, do all this this extra work?</p> <p>The answer might be found in <em>LoL</em>’s curious market position which is atypical in the video game industry: people who play it often mostly play this single game and the company who makes it only has this one game on the market. Anything that makes the world richer or makes players more likely to invest time and money is clearly beneficial to its monovalent economic model, and perhaps the easiest way to do this is to systematically entice emotional investment in the characters. That is, merely by changing the character name from the generic “Dragon Knight” to the proper name “Shyvanna” and giving her a story, as a persecuted half-breed seeking revenge on her father’s murderer, the game feels richer (or stickier as investors might term it).</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/03_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/03_1.jpg?itok=xKBJgM-K" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>By contrast in <em>HotS</em>, there is no unifying narrative for the game itself. It is just a giant multi-dimensional brawl between all the proprietary characters from Blizzard’s other games. That means that, like in Nintendo’s hit Super Smash Brothers, the characters are all beloved by fans for their long-running stories in their respective games. The characters in <em>HotS</em> are mainly core playable characters in other franchises, or their equally famous villains. You can choose to play the hero of the StarCraft 2 series, Jim Raynor, whose lengthy wiki mentions GameSpot’s community voted him one of the top ten heroes in video gaming, or as Ilidan Stormrage, the villain from the World of Warcraft: Burning Crusade storyline, famous across the internet for his line, “You are not prepared,” which is used in an untold number of memes.</p> <p>These characters have often had numerous novels published about their exploits, as well as a bevy of toys, comics, cosplay, and loads of fan art and fan fiction made about them. This is big part of the appeal of the game, both for fans and for Blizzard’s investors. Old school players get to take control of a favorite character that they have grown up with while new players can discover (and of course buy) the other Blizzard games through an introduction to their main characters in <em>HotS</em>.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/04_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/04_2.jpg?itok=G90pPzd8" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>Art History Is For Noobs</strong></p> <p>Alongside the character names and stories, one aspect of picking a character that is noticeable even before you play a game is the art style. The style of art doesn’t get much conscious attention, buried as it is amongst the overwhelming practical choices given to new players, but the house art style of each game holds a wealth of interesting indications about how the games wish to present themselves.</p> <p><em>DotA2</em> is based on the game <em>Warcraft 3</em>, but has moved toward a more classic fantasy style with a focus on organic textures and stylized but still (vaguely) realistic proportions rooted in the tradition of 70s and 80s <em>Lord Of The Rings</em> or Dungeons &amp; Dragons oil paintings. Valve even created a whole new engine for the launch of <em>DotA2</em> just to handle natural fabric effects.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/05_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/05_1.jpg?itok=fSCJebCo" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>LoL</em> is curious because it started as a clone of <em>DotA</em> which initially featured rather middling classic comic-book style art and then evolved toward using highly wrought illustrations very rooted in late 90s-to-current mainstream cover illustrations from Marvel, DC, and Image with extreme physiques (think 20-pack abs and giant balloon boobs), use of forced perspective, and blindingly shiny dramatic lighting across a slew of neon colors.</p> <p>Riot is currently in the midst of a massive overhaul of its <em>LoL</em> art. They are trying to remove most of the remnant assets from their early years, often replacing them with assets created for the newer Korean and Chinese versions of the game, which has a nod toward anime and manga. The old art character style is maybe best represented by the notorious Snow Bunny Nidalee, and the new style is certainly represented by Nightblade Irelia or Neon Vi.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/06_2.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/06_2.jpg?itok=NiTfDy_w" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em>HotS</em> continues the Blizzard house style which is rooted in 70’s fantasy-comedy illustration, itself a product of the head shop culture and underground “comix”, with highly cartoonish, thick bodies. There are bell bottom pants galore, barrel-chested men, curvy women, and oversized shoulder armor, and fists that often literally look like hams when formed with polygons.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/07_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/07_1.jpg?itok=R3smcmY6" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Moneychanger Lurking In The Shadows</strong></p> <p>While picking your first character, the differing economic models of the games are immediately highlighted. In <em>DotA2</em> you immediately have full access to every character in the game at their full power. Though egalitarian, this makes for a daunting decision for new players, given that there are 110 different options! Throwing new players into the deep end is actually something of a point of pride in the <em>DotA2</em> community. They revel in the steepness of the learning curve as a defining feature of what makes their game interesting and fair. Once you’ve picked a character in <em>DotA2</em>, the game then highlights different workshop accessories, which are alternate aesthetic models to customize every part of your character from boots, to gloves, to swords. These items don’t have any impact on the game and cost small amounts of money to buy, generally from $.99 to $4.00 USD.</p> <p>In <em>LoL</em>, they have 126 characters to play, but new players initially only have access to a set of 10 of those characters they can play for free. To permanently acquire a champion you can spend money, generally between $4 and $10 USD, or the in-game currency called “IP” that you gather slowly by playing matches. Newer characters cost the most, while older characters are cheaper. Each week another different set of 10 champions will be available for free so if you want to keep playing the character you liked you need to buy them. You can also buy aesthetic variants called skins since they replace the whole model for your character.</p> <p>With <em>HotS</em>, there is a similar free rotation system, but with only 5 characters available out of 39. The game also offers you a daily quest, which gives you bonus in-game money if you complete it, but requires you play either a character from a particular game world (World of Warcraft, StarCraft, etc) or from a specific role, which may or may not be available for free that week. <em>DotA2</em> has mostly stopped adding characters, <em>LoL</em> adds a new character about once a month, and <em>HotS</em> is still new enough that they are adding new characters fairly rapidly with the stated goal of adding characters as long as the game exists. Though as we’ll examine in later sections, the more characters a MOBA has, the more complicated it gets for the designers to balance the game play.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/08_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/08_1.jpg?itok=69kYD_2P" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><strong>The Othello Legacy</strong></p> <p>One curious statistic is that players connect with and hence prefer to buy humanoid characters over non-humanoid (such as blob or insect) characters by a statistically significant margin, even if the non-human characters are better. This is a key to looking at the ways that the companies try to convince players to spend money on the game. For instance, this statistic can be used to partially explain why <em>DotA2</em> has many more non-human champions than <em>LoL</em>: <em>DotA2</em> doesn’t have to sell you the character, just fun accessories like gemstone crowns and flaming swords, while <em>LoL</em> has to a deep financial incentive to get the player to emotionally identify with and thus acquire the character itself.</p> <p>One interesting way to examine the representational design decisions of MOBAs is by taking stock of what kinds of characters are made available. Given the innumerable issues with diversity in mainstream video games, whether it is gender, race, age, or disability, for the purposes of this article as a series of starting places for further research, the easiest statistic to count is the male to female representation of the playable characters.</p> <p>In <em>DotA2</em>, there are 89 playable characters that are male, 18 that are female, and 3 that have no assigned gender. For a closer breakdown there are 10 females that rely on “agility” and 7 on “intelligence” while there is only one female character who has “strength” as a primary statistic. Examining <em>LoL</em>, there are 83 male, 42 female, and 1 non-gendered, character. <em>HotS</em> has 27 male and 12 female characters. One choice that stands out in these numbers was that all three games generally assign a traditional gender to a character even if they are a strange floating eyeball, mutant insect, or energy being, something that would exist outside of our social paradigms of gender.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/09.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/09.jpg?itok=Mn2ZO75Z" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Compounding the already complicated conversation about diversity in video game representation, these three games are deeply rooted in the genre of fantasy literature. From Tolkien having the all the dark skinned men as part of Mordor’s army to <em>World of Warcraft</em>’s various fantasy races featuring accents and dances that correspond to non-white human societies, this genre has long had significant issues with racial representation and relegating non-white race to allegorical symbols (usually of the inhuman or monstrous variety).</p> <p>Given the further implications of these tropes, purely methodologically it is still tricky to get a count of racial representation in these three games. Do you count “dark” elves as black? “Panda” people as Chinese? How about heavy drinking, wode-wearing, axe-welding, Scottish-accented characters: Dwarf or Scotsman? Personally, in all fantasy and science fiction I find that sort of allegorical mapping to be artistic laziness (see <a href="http://www.revolutionsf.com/article.php?id=953">Michael Moorcock’s classic “Epic Pooh” essay</a>, or <a href="http://anoved.net/2012/03/thinking-critically-about-tolkien/">China Melville and David Brin’s thoughts about fantasy</a> cultures for an introduction to this line of avant fantasy thinking). But even leaving my bias aside, it certainly seems like a problematic implication that if you want to play a character that’s even vaguely darker-skinned you have to be a magic fairy-tale being or animal, probably with tusks or claws. Some of the many of the articles around the game <em>Witcher 3</em> have looked as this issue, my favorite of which is excellently researched article by Luke Maciak titled <a href="http://www.terminally-incoherent.com/blog/2015/06/04/witcher-3-and-diversity/">“Witcher 3 and Diversity”</a> ).</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">Do you count “dark” elves as black? “Panda” people as Chinese?</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Possibly the most straightforward way to look at this issue would be to count how many actual human characters there are and their skin color/race. This means even the most humanoid demon, elf, or dwarf is excluded from this count. <em>HotS</em> has 10 human characters, and all are white/Caucasian. Counting racial breakdown in <em>LoL</em> is far more tricky, since they rely on a combination of fantasy and super-hero tropes, along with their nebulous lolore, make the line between human and fae more blurry (i.e. does adding a tail to an otherwise totally normal human make it non-human or is that just fan-fashion? Is “Southern Ionia” mapped to India or another Southeast Asian state, or nothing specific at all?), but for a rough count there about are 46 human characters of which there are 32 white/Caucasian, 8 Asian, 2 black, 2 Latin/Hispanic, and 2 from India/Southeast Asia.</p> <p><em>DotA2</em> has about 22 human characters, of which 17 are white/Caucasian, 1 Probably-Mongolian/Central Asian (given the title Khan), 1 Latin/Hispanic, 2 Middle Eastern, 1 Asian, and no black characters. Looking at the character art closely, one interesting note is that in <em>HotS</em>, human characters tend to have exceptionally pale-Nordic skin, while in <em>DotA2</em>, the human characters tend toward a rather darker Mediterranean skin tone.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/10_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/10_1.jpg?itok=Lf95RL3w" width="700" height="211" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Correlating these choices of representation to player demographics would be the next massive step, but for the sake of space, it will serve to note that one unique facet of Riot Games is that they have been the only MOBA game company willing to share some demographic and design information with the general public (which is a small part of the reason this article skews slightly toward discussing <em>LoL</em>). It has openly said that “over” 90% of the 67 million global players of <em>LoL</em> are male and 85% of those players are between 16 and 30 (and interestingly, 60% are college educated, or are in college). There is no publicly available demographic data for player nationalities, but we can generally infer that the major locations where players hail from are the ones that have the official professional leagues sponsored by the company, which are: North America, Korea, China, Southeast Asia, and Western Europe. Though South America does not have a full status league, it has professionally organized <em>LoL</em> play, as does Turkey.</p> <p><em>DotA2</em> is seemingly similar except it has such a large player base in Russia and Eastern Europe that they have an additional league there called CIS, but has almost no presence in the Korean market. It is unclear precisely where <em>HotS</em> will be popular, but the upcoming world final has the same regional breakdown as <em>LoL</em>.</p> <p>In next week’s installment of “Demystifying Mobas &amp; Esports” we’ll be staying with the characters. The focus will shift from artistic representations to examine some of the differences in core design philosophy between these three games. Each game has a very defined idea of how characters should be empowered to act, and what sort of methods of interaction the players should have with these digital pantheons.</p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction">Part 1 - Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> </ul> </div> <section class="comments"> <h2 class="comments__title">Kommentare</h2> <div class="comments__list"><article data-comment-user-id="0" id="comment-2962" class="comment js-comment"> <mark class="hidden" data-comment-user-id="0"></mark> <header class="comment__meta"> <span class="comment__author"><span class="username">Jonas</span></span> <span class="node__sep" aria-hidden="true">·</span> <span class="comment__date">Mi. 9 Sep 2015 - 11:23</span> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/comment/2962#comment-2962" hreflang="und">Permalink</a> </header> <div class="comment__content prose-content"> <h3 class="comment__title"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/comment/2962#comment-2962" class="permalink" rel="bookmark" hreflang="und">Very nice assessment</a></h3> <div class="field field--name-comment-body field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Thanks a lot for this article, I thoroughly enjoyed the read. This is really an intelligent analysis of the current MOBA sector, also from an economic view. As a gamer in his mid 30ies I really like to discuss things like this. ;)</p> </div> </div> </article> </div> </section> Mon, 07 Sep 2015 18:41:30 +0000 Eron Rauch 621 at https://videogametourism.at Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-introduction-introduction <span>Demystifying MOBAs: An Introduction to an Introduction</span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/bridging-worlds_1.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/bridging-worlds_1.jpg?itok=3rU9AuZg" width="700" height="200" alt> </a> </div> <span><a title="Benutzerprofil anzeigen." href="https://videogametourism.at/users/eron-rauch" class="username">Eron Rauch</a></span> <span><time datetime="2015-08-24T10:12:45+02:00" title="Montag, 24 August 2015 - 10:12">Mo. 24 Aug 2015 - 10:12</time> </span> <div class="field field--name-field-teaser field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p><em><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds">Bridging Worlds</a> is a series by LA-based artist and VGT author <a href="http://www.eronrauch.com/">Eron Rauch</a> about the blurred line between games and art. His multi-part essay "Demystifying MOBAs" takes an in-depth look at the game design of esports and MOBAs.</em></p> <p><em>“And the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we started and to know the place for the first time.” T.S. Elliot</em></p> <p><em>“Every art is produced by the tension between a series of aims and a series of resistances to their achievement…” Arnold Hauser</em></p> <p>The triple glories of money, terror, and fame rule the landscape of the mass media press. On the rare occasions when they talk about video games, this usually means that we get to hear about the creator of <em>Minecraft</em> outbidding Jay Z and Beyonce for his new house, some attempt to shoehorn a troubled youth’s love of <em>Call of Duty</em> into his violent behavior, or the inevitable hyperbole about how Hollywood has been superseded in revenue by the video game industry.</p> <p>But one curious manifestation of the American fixation on the spectacular is that, when it comes to coverage of video games, the two games that have received the highest profile and subsequently the most exposure to non-game-fans, are two of the most opaque to outsiders and the least covered by the game criticism community. The games are <em>League of Legends</em> (Riot Games) and <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (Valve).</p> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-element field--type-entity-reference-revisions field--label-hidden field__items"> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/taking-the-count-riven_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/taking-the-count-riven_0.jpg?itok=Je5QJF7t" width="700" height="827" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Both are in the genre that is typically called Multiplayer Online Battle Arenas, or MOBAs for short. These games are something more than games, combining public performance, money, adrenaline, and fame, they are spectacle incarnate; they are the two most popular esports. Much like football, basketball, or baseball, these two games pack stadiums, create wealthy stars, and have millions and millions of fans around the world.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">MOBAs combine public performance, money, adrenaline, and fame, they are spectacle incarnate.</div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Both of these games have dominated video game news in the American mainstream media in 2014 and 2015, principally because of the narrative of the meteoric rise of esports in America, Europe, and Asia amongst youth culture. <em>League of Legends</em> (aka <em>LoL</em>), it is often noted, has far more people playing at any one time than <em>World of Warcraft</em> had total subscribers at its peak. Riot even had enough clout to lobby a notoriously fickle and glacial United States Congress to change visa law to allow for sports visas to be used for professional video game players. The 2014 <em>LoL</em> finals packed out the Seoul World Cup football stadium and had almost 30,000,000 people watch it worldwide, which for some perspective was the audience for the NBA basketball finals and baseball’s World Series combined. Though it has a much smaller fan base, <em>Defense of the Ancients 2</em> (<em>DotA2</em>) often gets major coverage because its premier tournament, The International, tends to have outlandish prize pools that rival most professional poker tournaments, with this year’s International 5 having a pot of $17,736,704 USD and being held in Seattle’s professional basketball arena.</p> <p>To add to the story, mega-company Blizzard/Activision has placed their own entry, called <em>Heroes of the Storm</em> (<em>HotS</em>), into the esports fray with a massive global inaugural tournament announced only months after its launch. Given that Blizzard is a founding pillar of the esports community with <em>Starcraft</em>, it is clear they mean to compete at the top end of the market. Even when the game was in closed beta testing, they already had multiple leagues underway all around the world, featuring the top clans, A-list teams, celebrity players, and wealthy sponsors.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/lol-season-1-vs-season-4-championship.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/lol-season-1-vs-season-4-championship.jpg?itok=jnLyRc7C" width="700" height="325" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>So with these three games poised to monopolize even more press in 2015, the question becomes how to talk about them past the simple press narrative of lots of prize money and young suddenly famous pro-player-geeks (a popular press narrative in the age of geek-as-perfect-consumer-demographic). A few articles have addressed the legitimately terrible reputation and behavior of these communities and the relative lack of women in these games, but without much explanation or exploration of how that reputation was formed, maintained, or combatted. The broader problem in talking about video games in a nuanced way is massively amplified with MOBAs since all three games are tricky for both lay and academic audiences, especially since it can take literally hundreds of hours to learn to play these games with any amount of skill, let alone to explore their communities. But the seeming complexity of the ever-evolving professional level of gameplay actually masks a large number of broadly interesting and highly accessible starting points for even the casually curious.</p> <p>One specific impetus for writing this article is my recent art show, <em>Night Walks &amp; Valhalla</em>, featured work utilizing these three MOBAs as source material. Patrons of the fine art world can often be squeamish around video games anyway, but at the opening for the show even the few lovers of video games were openly admitted how they felt MOBAs were alien and impossibly opaque. Even when I talk with game designers and writers, the sentiment that MOBAs are inscrutable (and perhaps of dubious value) is common. This piece is an attempt to create a series of introductions and interactions that would allow anyone, MOBA player or not, skeptic or not, to find a way to access the ways the games, their communities, and the rise of esports tie in to a larger cultural context.</p> <p>Two sources of inspiration which showed that such a bridge-building endeavor is possible were a pair of recent shows at the Los Angeles Museum of Art which looked at the relationship of sporting and the arts. First was <a href="http://www.lacma.org/art/exhibition/manly-pursuits-sporting-images-thomas-eakins">Manly Pursuits: The Sporting Images Of Thomas Eakins</a> which featured large scale paintings of athletes by one of America’s great 19th century artists. The second was <a href="http://www.lacma.org/art/exhibition/futbol-beautiful-game">Futbol: The Beautiful Game</a> which took a global and multimedia look at the way that the many beauties and problems with football has inspired art in the 21st century. In both shows it was clear how art and sports could be used in tandem to examine each other and the larger cultural landscape which houses them.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/rauch-eron-waiting-for-.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/rauch-eron-waiting-for-.jpg?itok=Yc171SRk" width="700" height="467" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Because I’ve been playing these video games and watching tons of esports for reasons other than their intended purpose (though I genuinely enjoy them) I’ve become obsessed with their curious, subtle, and weird details. These are possibly the best starting places to demystifying MOBAs. Even though this series might seem more focused on deconstructing the technical elements of video game design, it is precisely my goal to create a broad series of potentially new ways to talk about these three games and the culture of esports. Some of these views are going to be quite oblique or tangential, since I find that often systematic subtleties are more clearly revealed by looking at the subject from non-standard perspectives. It is completely okay that any given reader is probably not going find all avenues of investigation equally interesting. Each section of this series is intended both as basic information and also as a prompt; as prismatic fractures that will hopefully serve some artist, critic, or curious reader as a starting point for their own exploration of <em>LoL, DotA2, HotS</em>, and of the rise of esports.</p> <p>Let me re-emphasize that despite looking like a primer, this series will not help you parse a Twitch video of frenzied professional commentators in eye-melting suits rambling about the in-game nuances of things such as, “caster minion aggro lane freezing,” “aggressive tri-lane rotations,” or “anti-counter jungle ward placement.” If you want that, you’ll just have to hop into games, be really bad for a really long time, get called lots of nasty names, and slowly learn. Heaven help you if you’re over 27. That said, it will be valuable to give at least the the most rudimentary overview of these games.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/league-of-legends-heroes.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/league-of-legends-heroes.jpg?itok=iSfDUVkA" width="700" height="229" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Though the companies disagree on the precise term to call this genre, all three share a large amount of traits. They are 5 vs 5 team competitive games, with each player selecting of a character, moving them around in a 3/4 overhead view with their mouse and using the keyboard to cast their abilities. They all share a single root, which is a fan-created mod of <em>Warcraft 3</em>, and as such share a great deal of similarity with both other real-time strategy games, which emphasize quick decision making and precision movement, and also with fantasy role playing games which emphasize leveling up your character, selecting spells, and utilizing abilities to exploit the weakness of the opponents.</p> <p>I’ll address the maps in more detail in the third section, but each team has a base on opposite sides of the map and the win condition is to destroy that base. The map is divided into lanes, which are protected by towers, and which various NPC (Non Player Characters) minions constantly spawn and walk down, mindlessly fighting. Players divide up in various ways in these lanes, and try to collect gold and/or experience from these minions, all while fighting the other team. The region between the lanes is generally called the jungle and players can roam through it to help other lanes, kill the monsters within, or to hide.</p> <p>Since the game is played double-blind, where characters can only see what their teammates can see, much of the game relies on tracking and predicting what your opponents are doing. The games usually have a laning phase (so-called because it mostly happens in the lanes), where the players collect basic resources, which then evolves into ever more fighting and maneuvering with the full 5-person team. When players die, they respawn, with the timers getting longer as the game goes on. Games typically end when one team either becomes overwhelmingly stronger or when one team makes a mistake late in the game and has so many people dead that they can’t defend their base.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-bild paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-paragraph-image field--type-image field--label-hidden field__item"> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/futbol_0.jpg" class="glightbox"><img loading="lazy" src="https://videogametourism.at/sites/default/files/styles/700_width/public/futbol_0.jpg?itok=jGLlYvE5" width="700" height="776" alt> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>For the remaining sections of “Demystifying MOBAs and Esports,” my method is going to be comparing and contrasting the many choices these games make both in their design and their presentation of themselves as a massively public sport. Though art historians often have a tendency to produce ranking systems, if just by necessity because of the very limited space in any given art history text, the most interesting conversations about art have typically been amongst groups of interrelated projects so each can highlight the subtle variations of the others. I know these three games all have stark partisans, but it is far more valuable to give each their due, because looking at how they each try different methods to approach the same issues, and often even overtly revise each other’s perceived shortcomings, tells us far more about the ramifications and results of these games and esports growing to prominence in culture. It is through the prismatic splay of their details that we can gather the most interesting inroads into the conflicts, nuances, and cultures that occur in these games. For the hardcore fans, much of this stuff might seem rudimentary or simplistic (after all, one of the great joys of these games is that every statement has multiple exceptions), but learning to peer at these subtle modulations is critical to getting a handle on finding a broader perspective that connects the historic, economic, social, and artistic forces of these juggernauts.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-marginalie paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-marginalie field--type-string-long field--label-hidden field__item">The rise of MOBAs and esports has made our current world more reminiscent of Philip K. Dick's than Isaac Asimov's fantasies. </div> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>This month starts the frenzy anew, with <em>DotA2</em>’s The International 5, and the inevitable headlines about 8 digit prize pools fresh in recent memory. Then in October, one of the most anticipated tournaments in esports history, the <em>LoL</em> Season 5 World Finals, will happen and is sure to shatter every previous esport viewing record. Finally, Blizzcon kicks into high gear sweeping hoards over the Disneyland convention center in the California in November to watch the top teams on <em>HotS</em> fight.</p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field__item"> <div class="paragraph paragraph--type-absatz-mit-initiale paragraph--view-mode-default"> <div class="field field--name-field-absatz field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>So grab a beer, and settle in to see the innumerable highly regimented youthful teams sponsored by top tech companies playing video games in packed sports arenas while millions of fans cheer them on from around the globe, none of whom are watching these events on television. Though so many people want to discuss the virtual reality headset boom as the future-come-true, the rise of MOBAs and esports is in my eyes far stranger and far more more science fiction than walking though any virtual world could be, no matter how high the polygon count. Think of this essay as examining the infrastructure and attitudes that has made our current world so much more like Philip K. Dick than Asimov.</p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-characters-representing-digital-pantheon">Part 2 - Demystifying MOBAs: Characters - Representing A Digital Pantheon</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-pantheon-action">Part 3 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Pantheon in Action</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-charming-stroll-through-flatlands-battlefield">Part 4 - Demystifying MOBAs: A Charming Stroll Through Flatland’s Battlefield</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-play-gory-farming-glory">Part 5 - Demystifying MOBAs: PLAY - The Gory Farming of Glory</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-history-speed">Part 6 - Demystifying MOBAs: A History of Speed</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-grand-spectacle">Part 7 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Grand Spectacle</a></p> <p><a href="https://videogametourism.at/content/demystifying-mobas-heralds-high-drama">Part 8 - Demystifying MOBAs: The Heralds of High Drama</a></p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="field field--name-field-tags field--terms"> <ul class="terms"> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/bridging-worlds" hreflang="de">Bridging Worlds</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/english-feature" hreflang="de">English feature</a></li> <li class="terms__item"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/tags/demystifying-mobas" hreflang="de">Demystifying MOBAs</a></li> </ul> </div> <section class="comments"> <h2 class="comments__title">Kommentare</h2> <div class="comments__list"><article data-comment-user-id="0" id="comment-2961" class="comment js-comment"> <mark class="hidden" data-comment-user-id="0"></mark> <header class="comment__meta"> <span class="comment__author"><span class="username">Gast</span></span> <span class="node__sep" aria-hidden="true">·</span> <span class="comment__date">Di. 25 Aug 2015 - 18:59</span> <a href="https://videogametourism.at/comment/2961#comment-2961" hreflang="und">Permalink</a> </header> <div class="comment__content prose-content"> <h3 class="comment__title"><a href="https://videogametourism.at/comment/2961#comment-2961" class="permalink" rel="bookmark" hreflang="und">Bis vor drei Monaten hatte</a></h3> <div class="field field--name-comment-body field--type-text-long field--label-hidden field__item"><p>Bis vor drei Monaten hatte ich mit MOBAs nichts am Hut.<br> Was sollte ich auch damit als alter Mann (über 40)?<br> Doch habe ich spontan ohne jegliche Erwartungen HotS probiert.<br> Solchen Adrenalinrausch und Emotionen habe ich selten beim Gamen erlebt. Mittlerweile so gegen 600 Matches gespielt. Das Spiel aus Wut viermal deinstalliert um später es erneut zu installieren.<br> Sogar mit richtigem Sport angefangen und mit dem Trinken aufgehört.<br> Verschiedene MOBAs ausprobiert. Und letzthin mich ertappt, wie ich auf Twitch die HotS Meisterschaften mitverfolgt habe.</p> </div> </div> </article> </div> </section> Mon, 24 Aug 2015 08:12:45 +0000 Eron Rauch 617 at https://videogametourism.at